Ok

So a lot of film critics are beating themselves off to the the idea that the First Order as an alt-right stand in.

But here's the thing. They executed it so bad that it actually came out the opposite.

The reality is the alt right just want to be left alonr

And they wouldn't have put a dindu in the military and given him weapon

The First Order isn't a bunch bratty kids cosplaying in their graddads SS uniform. Generationally speaking they're baby boomers.

I don't believe that's what the Alt-right is

We are not discussing Siege larpers

False equivalency, the alt right doesn't have institutional power

Neither do I, but that is how the critics and the people that made this movie see it.

Fair enough

I agree. I am explaining the failburger that is the plot of this thing.

Ok. I recognize that they're an idiot's idea of what the alt-right is, but how are they analogous to the hippie movement?

Because they're first generation. They're the kids of the people that fought and defeated the Empire. As Personified in Kylo Ren. That makes them baby boomers.

Throughout the first movie and much of the second Kylo is conflicted about his identity and who he is. This was an aspect of the hippie movement.

Then towards the end of TLJ he overthrows his master (symbloic of leftist conquest of academia, maybe?) and declares that his goal is to destory and unmake everything constructed by his parents. All the old traditions. Manifested in the Jedi Order.

Ok. But that's what he turns the first order into. That's not what it was from the outset

Rey on the other hand rejects this proposition and declares there is something worth preserving in the old ways and traditions.

Random, but is anyone familiar with Cicada 3301?

Yeah.

Its founder would have been alive during the galactic civil war

No

Yeah, I read an article about Cicada 3301. You gotta be a big-brained nibba

You got me in a spoopy mood

My almonds are too small

Bad writing there. Snoke needed some kind of background. One of the worst things to ever happen to SW lore. Just like how you can apparently quit the jedi order with no consequences and run around the galaxy with force powers ala count dooku.

But as a result it's easy to project Snoke into being a Frankfurt school professor who is tryiing to use a hippie to increase his own political power.

Holy shit what's this wall of text

Sometime i gotta pull down my pants and take a geek lore dump on somone's face.

But snoke clearly wants the first order to succeed the empire. He's not interested in destroying everything like Kylo is

This is why kylo kills him. Their goals are not alligned

Kylo doesn't want to destroy everything. He wants to recreate galactic order in his own image. Snoke wants that as well. Kylo describes that in terms of wanted to break "traditional power structures"

It's pretty bog standard EU stih power struggle crap funny enough.

Yes, but snoke basically wants to recreate the empire. Kylo doesn't want his new system to resemble anything else that's come before

Why did they even need the snow troopers when the planet surface was a salt flat?

They're not snow troopers. They're salt troopers.

That doesn't make any sense.

All that salt from the tears of the SJW rebels.

No one else in that battle was wearing protective gear, or seemed like they would have really needed it at any point in time

Nooo, they gotta be faceless because symbolism and shit.