Message from @Kingfish

Discord ID: 522184106096984064


2018-12-11 22:49:02 UTC  

We iz kang? 🤔

2018-12-11 22:49:35 UTC  

objectively you don't have as good a claim as he does

2018-12-11 22:49:35 UTC  

There is no legal claim to the throne it doesnt exist. If he was installed as a monarch it woundnt be invalid either though.

2018-12-11 22:50:10 UTC  

You would have a better argument if the French Monarchy was still a thing

2018-12-11 22:50:11 UTC  

yeah he renounced it (legally, with due process), but he's actually french and of the line. none of us are

2018-12-11 22:50:11 UTC  

thats way different than the argument you were making earlier

2018-12-11 22:50:32 UTC  

@Sam Southern - TN by renouncing legal claim it doesn't matter how close by blood he is he has no legal claim

2018-12-11 22:50:54 UTC  

He has more of right to the throne because of his noble birth

2018-12-11 22:50:56 UTC  

lol I'm not arguing legal claim, he has a *better* claim than you or any of us do

2018-12-11 22:51:18 UTC  

Not more of a claim than Henri @MrDefault

2018-12-11 22:51:41 UTC  

Guys Kings are made because their Lords fight for them. Pedigrees are legal nonsense.

2018-12-11 22:51:48 UTC  

This is great stuff. I recommend giving this a listen/watch.
Watch "A New French Revolution? (Gilets Jaunes)" on YouTube
https://youtu.be/pr8J1RjknLI

2018-12-11 22:51:49 UTC  

you said he was legitimate "He is legitimate. He cant inherit Spain."

2018-12-11 22:51:58 UTC  

which neither of these are accurate

2018-12-11 22:52:12 UTC  

actually he can't inherit spain anymore so that part is

2018-12-11 22:52:21 UTC  

but if anything he has a way better claim to spain

2018-12-11 22:52:37 UTC  

Unless these fops get 10,000 soldiers to March on the capital theyre not monarchs in any sense.

2018-12-11 22:52:44 UTC  

@Kingfish I said theoretically he could claim both Spain, France and England.

2018-12-11 22:52:50 UTC  

where

2018-12-11 22:52:59 UTC  

scroll up

2018-12-11 22:53:12 UTC  

nvm see it but he can't claim france at all

2018-12-11 22:53:17 UTC  

he could try to claim spain

2018-12-11 22:53:19 UTC  

I'd back that

2018-12-11 22:53:23 UTC  

He could though

2018-12-11 22:53:29 UTC  

Loyalists support him

2018-12-11 22:53:45 UTC  

okay thats cool I'm saying he doesnt have a legal claim

2018-12-11 22:53:58 UTC  

If they seized power they couldnt annul the treaty of Utrecth

2018-12-11 22:53:59 UTC  

wait who's claiming England?

2018-12-11 22:54:00 UTC  

sure he could overthrow the government and instate himself find

2018-12-11 22:54:18 UTC  

seizing power does not equal inherit.

2018-12-11 22:54:21 UTC  

you know that

2018-12-11 22:54:26 UTC  

Under the grounds that France needs a rightful monarch

2018-12-11 22:54:28 UTC  

Anyone who siezes power can do whatever they want by definition

2018-12-11 22:54:31 UTC  

he cannot legally INHERIT the french throne

2018-12-11 22:54:32 UTC  

That's what power means

2018-12-11 22:54:36 UTC  

he can take it I guess

2018-12-11 22:54:41 UTC  

but thats not a legal inheritance

2018-12-11 22:54:41 UTC  

Legality is for peasents

2018-12-11 22:54:45 UTC  

The way things stand no one can INHERIT the throne

2018-12-11 22:54:50 UTC  

sure

2018-12-11 22:54:52 UTC  

There is no throne