Message from @Kingfish
Discord ID: 522183893390983188
okay bud
the dude is of the same line that renounced all claims by legal treaty
he can claim it all he wants
but it is not a legal claim anymore
I have just as good claim as he does
We iz kang? 🤔
objectively you don't have as good a claim as he does
There is no legal claim to the throne it doesnt exist. If he was installed as a monarch it woundnt be invalid either though.
You would have a better argument if the French Monarchy was still a thing
yeah he renounced it (legally, with due process), but he's actually french and of the line. none of us are
thats way different than the argument you were making earlier
@Sam Southern - TN by renouncing legal claim it doesn't matter how close by blood he is he has no legal claim
He has more of right to the throne because of his noble birth
lol I'm not arguing legal claim, he has a *better* claim than you or any of us do
Not more of a claim than Henri @MrDefault
Guys Kings are made because their Lords fight for them. Pedigrees are legal nonsense.
This is great stuff. I recommend giving this a listen/watch.
Watch "A New French Revolution? (Gilets Jaunes)" on YouTube
https://youtu.be/pr8J1RjknLI
you said he was legitimate "He is legitimate. He cant inherit Spain."
which neither of these are accurate
actually he can't inherit spain anymore so that part is
Unless these fops get 10,000 soldiers to March on the capital theyre not monarchs in any sense.
@Kingfish I said theoretically he could claim both Spain, France and England.
where
scroll up
nvm see it but he can't claim france at all
he could try to claim spain
I'd back that
He could though
Loyalists support him
okay thats cool I'm saying he doesnt have a legal claim
If they seized power they couldnt annul the treaty of Utrecth
wait who's claiming England?
sure he could overthrow the government and instate himself find
seizing power does not equal inherit.
you know that
Under the grounds that France needs a rightful monarch
Anyone who siezes power can do whatever they want by definition
he cannot legally INHERIT the french throne
That's what power means
he can take it I guess