Message from @Norman

Discord ID: 789623076693606403


2020-12-18 22:38:05 UTC  

What if someone is coming from a place where they would otherwise have died?

2020-12-18 22:38:09 UTC  

too bad

2020-12-18 22:38:14 UTC  

go somewhere else

2020-12-18 22:38:19 UTC  

So we should just let them die?

2020-12-18 22:38:24 UTC  

no, we will take them in

2020-12-18 22:38:29 UTC  

as laborers in prison

2020-12-18 22:38:41 UTC  

okay so norman

2020-12-18 22:38:42 UTC  

you ever read the story utopia?

2020-12-18 22:38:54 UTC  

people would emmigrate to that country

2020-12-18 22:38:59 UTC  

and then the country would enslave them

2020-12-18 22:39:02 UTC  

You're basing your ideal society off of a book from a few thousand years ago?

2020-12-18 22:39:02 UTC  

you believe that if they come here after deportation it should be forced labor or death yes?

2020-12-18 22:39:14 UTC  

not that long ago, less then 1 thousand

2020-12-18 22:39:25 UTC  

forced labor yes

2020-12-18 22:39:30 UTC  

deportation yes

2020-12-18 22:39:36 UTC  

death if they are dangerous

2020-12-18 22:39:38 UTC  

Still, their standards for what makes a good society are very different from modern standards

2020-12-18 22:39:43 UTC  

ok so?

2020-12-18 22:39:47 UTC  

morality doesnt change

2020-12-18 22:40:06 UTC  

Morality back then said that we could enslave people because they were black

2020-12-18 22:40:11 UTC  

ok so?

2020-12-18 22:40:21 UTC  

"forced labor yes
deportation yes
death if they are dangerous"

2020-12-18 22:40:21 UTC  

Do you think that doing that isn't immoral?

2020-12-18 22:40:24 UTC  

so

2020-12-18 22:40:33 UTC  

no relevance to present conversation

2020-12-18 22:40:41 UTC  

their crime is entering here illegaly yes norman?

2020-12-18 22:40:44 UTC  

How isn't it relevant?

2020-12-18 22:40:48 UTC  

yes

2020-12-18 22:40:53 UTC  

I'm using the same argument you did

2020-12-18 22:41:03 UTC  

and the lowering of wages is the moral charge yes?

2020-12-18 22:41:11 UTC  

i wasnt arguing from the book, i was making a connection to explain it better

2020-12-18 22:41:11 UTC  

I also don't get what you mean by this

2020-12-18 22:41:20 UTC  

Oh

2020-12-18 22:41:26 UTC  

well also they dont have any right to be here. wages is one negative impact

2020-12-18 22:41:35 UTC  

I see so

2020-12-18 22:41:41 UTC  

i believe in objective morality

2020-12-18 22:41:53 UTC  

Could you explain that?

2020-12-18 22:41:54 UTC  

GG @Benny, you just advanced to level 1!

2020-12-18 22:42:06 UTC  

As in, things are pretty black and white morally speaking?

2020-12-18 22:42:13 UTC  

i dont believe morality is just "whatever the norms of the society are" they are a real thing, as real as math

2020-12-18 22:42:16 UTC  

should the punishment for trespassing be forced labor or death norman?