Calling into question someone's citizenship is a bad idea

i think its only applicable to non-citizens babies

Yeah and at some point a lot of people had non citizen parents

doubt it will be back-dated.... probably only "from now"

And if their child was not made a citizen

to stop pregnant women illegally crossing the border

isn't this how most counteries do it?

Then a huge amount of people would have questioned citizenship

no they wouldnt

I think this is just against anchor babies

i mean, citicenship based on parents is pretty common around the globe

not really, because the counteries the parents are from typically give the child citizenship anyhow

only if its back-dated... which I doubt it would be

you dont get german citicenship for being born in germany for example. or japan

But I'm not saying it will be back dated

doubt it

It will still question citizenship

how?

if its just to stop pregnant women crossing the border why would they back date it

thats more work and hassle

its to stop birth tourism right?

Let's imagine my great grand parents were not citizens and had children who were

it is

read the article itself Codes

"The Supreme Court has already ruled that children born to immigrants who are legal permanent residents have citizenship. But those who claim the 14th Amendment should not apply to everyone point to the fact that there has been no ruling on a case specifically involving undocumented immigrants or those with temporary legal status."

its gonna be for anchor babies

Well that law would make my parents have questionable citizenship therefore questioning my citizenship

or... more likely trump will do a trumpism and say "its back dated" ... then a few months later say ok its not backdated... so the original thing is "not as bad"

thats only true if its back dated

if it isn't back dated, you're parents are citizens and their kids will be, and so will their's

Back dated or not a lot of people will question

And it's stupid to have that kinda precedent

if its not back dated its not affecting anyone

tahts literally how most counteries run citizenship

if your parents are legal residents, but not US citizens, then you WILL be given the right to citizenship

unless they are literally giving birth as its signed

i'm confused at wtf the problem is

said by the Supreme court itself apparently

The policy stems from the Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment tothe United States Constitution. The 1868 text states, "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."

Lots of people are born here to people with visas on there way to citizenship

And it would hurt those people too