Message from @Bayesed

Discord ID: 520057590311288840


2018-12-06 02:00:34 UTC  

So, you want physical objects?

2018-12-06 02:00:40 UTC  

I would posit what evidence confirms the existence of an absolute being

2018-12-06 02:00:46 UTC  

Damn, just when i need an actual doctor opinion, Cat is nowhere to be seen

2018-12-06 02:00:54 UTC  

@Beemann the quest for evidence inevitably results in erecting strawmans. You realize that right.

2018-12-06 02:00:56 UTC  

I'd want some sort of predictive factor or measurable object

2018-12-06 02:01:03 UTC  

Why does existence provide evidence for the being?

2018-12-06 02:01:23 UTC  

Many religious people would argue that consciousness in itself is evidence of God. Hence the famous quote from René Descartes, "I think therefore I am."

2018-12-06 02:01:30 UTC  

@Beemann alright. Predict the path of individual water molecules in a wave.

2018-12-06 02:01:36 UTC  

Well, I'm sorry, it is a bit difficult to provide measurable objects that provide evidence for a non-physical entity without introducing logical proofs.

2018-12-06 02:01:40 UTC  

Why would consciousness be evidence for god?

2018-12-06 02:01:44 UTC  

This is why we have philosophy.

2018-12-06 02:01:46 UTC  

If we as conscious beings envision a divine being connecting us together then it becomes an issue of belief rather than evidence.

2018-12-06 02:01:49 UTC  

@Bayesed why does it not

2018-12-06 02:02:03 UTC  

existence, consciousness, therefore god? it seems a bit of a leap

2018-12-06 02:02:33 UTC  

Im not saying youre wrong for belief in god. I am asking for your justification of your beliefs. convince me with evidence

2018-12-06 02:02:50 UTC  

Is your definition of evidence the same as Bees?

2018-12-06 02:02:54 UTC  

@Bayesed you literally just did earlier

2018-12-06 02:03:02 UTC  

no

2018-12-06 02:03:04 UTC  

Beliefs, by their nature, don't require justification or evidence

2018-12-06 02:03:10 UTC  

otherwise they'd be fact, not beleif

2018-12-06 02:03:11 UTC  

i said your 100% certainty was unfounded

2018-12-06 02:03:19 UTC  

What? All beliefs are rooted in some kind of justification.

2018-12-06 02:03:28 UTC  

@Bookworm is this where we get back into presupposition? Because I'm really tired of that one

2018-12-06 02:03:31 UTC  

The human mind holds no facts, only beliefs. Facts are external realities.

2018-12-06 02:03:53 UTC  

@Bayesed wrong. You did when you talked about vaccines.

2018-12-06 02:04:03 UTC  

just as an offhand comment

2018-12-06 02:04:06 UTC  

belief in the demons etc? yes

2018-12-06 02:04:09 UTC  

not about god

2018-12-06 02:04:14 UTC  

the Anti-Anti Vaxxers are int he camp of the Anti-Flat earth folks

2018-12-06 02:04:20 UTC  

I hear more from them than I do the actual Anti Vaxxers.

2018-12-06 02:04:26 UTC  

So, you will say people who believe in demons are wrong, but not God?

2018-12-06 02:04:31 UTC  

@Salacious Swanky Cat sorry? I have to personally mathematically run through the proofs for everything despite them being applicable in predictive models?

2018-12-06 02:04:32 UTC  

What's the critical separation?

2018-12-06 02:04:37 UTC  

im also not 100% certain that demons etc dont exist. but i have not seen supporting evidence so i assign it a very low probability near 0

2018-12-06 02:04:58 UTC  

that is bayesian probability

2018-12-06 02:05:08 UTC  

I think I understand why you think that this road leads to strawmen, fam

2018-12-06 02:05:34 UTC  

if you think that existence and consciousness are evidence of god

2018-12-06 02:05:45 UTC  

why not evidence of the simulation hypothesis? and we are a computer program etc?

2018-12-06 02:05:55 UTC  
2018-12-06 02:06:04 UTC  

@Beemann there isn’t a proven predictive model for individual molecules. Large amount of molecules.

2018-12-06 02:06:06 UTC  

My head