Message from @ConceptHut
Discord ID: 507391408253173771
What is the objective moral standard? Can any of you actually state what it is, this thing you're certain exists?
the same way peoples understanding of physics were similar across cultures
@Deleted User - Would putting you on a cross change your mind?
It was reality that shaped those beliefs in how the world operates
Ie. Murder is objectively bad. But murder in self defense is subjectively good or bad depending on the culture
@Roarey - It's a big formula homie.
And through how reality made what is objective about reality apparent
we can better understand morality
Does everyone talking have a mic and headset?
Theft is objectively bad. But type of theft and from who and why can be good or bad culturally
@Goblin_Slayer_Floki
In America, self defense == good
In Britbongistan, self defense == bad
But in both murder is bad
Example of morality being objective and subjective at the same time
Are mathematics an objective truth?
@Deleted User - Legally and socialy don't really make a thing bad or good, only bad or good to them. Good and bad in the general conversations people have is related to something more like natural law kind of context.
yes
You know, I've had a swell idea. How about, who gives a shit.
@Goblin_Slayer_Floki murder isn't objectively bad. It is bad if you value human life, if you believe human beings deserve to live. It also depends on what the definition of murder is, which is something people have to agree on by way of enshrining it in law.
@meratrix the religious zealot obviously
and is it something that exists irrespective of human conciseness?
depends on who or what you are murdering
Again all nations and cultures abhore cold blooded murder.
@ConceptHut You fail to understand the point of my statement I see.
The implimentation of what quantifies cold blooded is the subjective part
@meratrix - What was your point?
What about hot blooded murders? Is that a thing?
@Goblin_Slayer_Floki yes, but note that what cultures decide actually constitutes murder is what varies. Example: in Islam, killing an unbeliever is not murder.
if you kill a nuclear engineer for no reason who is trying to stop a reactor form going critical you are retarded and in the wrong all at once.
@ConceptHut "Crime of passion"
Are you going to answer the question?
Again thats implimentation vs base morality
@ConceptHut If you guys are all gonna discuss this and get absolutely nowhere after this long. You should move to voicechat because the conversation is becoming pointless in this format.
@Roarey killing a believer is bad. So implimentation vs base
You thought talking about morality would be a short conversation?
can whitey even enter vc?
@DanConway no, I'm done with you, since you can't be arsed supplying your own side of the argument, knowing that to avoid doing so protects your bullshit from me.
You might actually get somewhere if you guys talked it.
I cant working
Rip
@meratrix but then everyone would hear how gay dan sounds