Message from @kropotkin クロポトキン

Discord ID: 324323085048217610


2017-06-13 22:47:53 UTC  

I can agree with that, but I think all socialist governments are like that.

2017-06-13 22:47:56 UTC  

Socialism is democratic, socialism is communal, socialism is not a dictatorial government doing whatever they want with the economy

2017-06-13 22:48:11 UTC  

Well yeah because every socialist government based itself on Russia's model

2017-06-13 22:48:53 UTC  

With one exception that I know of which is revolutionary Catalonia

2017-06-13 22:49:09 UTC  

But that was overrun by fascists in the Spanish civil war so

2017-06-13 22:50:02 UTC  

I agree with that but so what's your idea of socialism and having a socialist government?

2017-06-13 22:51:08 UTC  

I, along with anyone who's not some sort of Stalin apologist, would probably support a purely democratic government and an economy that is truly owned and operated by the workers

2017-06-13 22:51:42 UTC  

And how would it be owned and operated by workers?

2017-06-13 22:52:18 UTC  

Well one was is Syndicalism, it's like a republic flipped upside down

2017-06-13 22:52:37 UTC  

Representatives don't represent, they take orders

2017-06-13 22:52:48 UTC  

Way is*

2017-06-13 22:54:58 UTC  

And your business or whatever you call it would operate itself, send a representative to a local trade union, which would coordinate the economy on a local level, which would then send a representative to the syndicate to organize the economy on an even larger scale, which would then send a representative to the Bourse du Travail which consists of syndicates working together on the basis of mutual consent

2017-06-13 22:56:25 UTC  

So your union would represent something like a small town, your Syndicate would operate something like a state, and the bourse du travail would operate the nation, only instead of the national level having the final say/authority it's the people

2017-06-13 22:57:11 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308995540782284817/324321334744186882/image.gif

2017-06-13 22:57:15 UTC  

Something like this

2017-06-13 23:01:30 UTC  

Alright, but who can start a business and hire employees?

2017-06-13 23:01:53 UTC  

You can come together as a group to form a business-like entity

2017-06-13 23:02:45 UTC  

But undemocratic private ownership is precisely what this system seeks to abolish

2017-06-13 23:02:51 UTC  

And replace

2017-06-13 23:03:37 UTC  

So one person can't own a business alone, or run it as he wants.

2017-06-13 23:04:09 UTC  

if you own it alone, you would have no one working for you

2017-06-13 23:05:08 UTC  

^ Why?

2017-06-13 23:05:38 UTC  

Well if it works out how Catalonia did, no one would be willing to work for you

2017-06-13 23:06:40 UTC  

Why wouldn't anyone be willing to work for me?

2017-06-13 23:07:19 UTC  

Because why would you work under the economic equivalent of a dictatorship when there's a shiny new democracy across the street

2017-06-13 23:10:02 UTC  

Not only would you then have a say in the business your income and possibly your life depends on, but you'd also be able to directly advocate for workers rights and your needs as workers

2017-06-13 23:11:30 UTC  

Just look at how effective things like unions are at advancing worker rights and pay

2017-06-13 23:12:50 UTC  

Unions are a modern failure now that businesses can afford to send workers to technical schools and butt unions workers out of the loop. They only get government contracts now and usually only state or federal projects.

2017-06-13 23:13:27 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308995540782284817/324325425042161665/image.jpg

2017-06-13 23:13:29 UTC  

Or at least that's my observation from the side of metal working and electrical unions.

2017-06-13 23:13:32 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308995540782284817/324325446986498048/image.png

2017-06-13 23:13:38 UTC  

Hold on there's one more

2017-06-13 23:13:55 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308995540782284817/324325542834733066/image.jpg

2017-06-13 23:14:26 UTC  

At least to me there seems to be a very strong correlation between the strength of unions and inequality

2017-06-13 23:14:46 UTC  

The value of the dollar has drastically dropped as wages increased.

2017-06-13 23:14:47 UTC  

A CEOs pay really doesn't matter. It's the CEO, he's going to accumulate wealth from his business, which is the whole purpose of starting a business in the first place. I wouldn't be comfortable with a government telling me that I need to trust someone who is hired with automatic privelege and shares to the company.

2017-06-13 23:15:06 UTC  

The CEO creates capital, which stimulates economic growth, and creates more jobs.

2017-06-13 23:15:12 UTC  

So why does the CEO's paycheck matter so much?

2017-06-13 23:15:21 UTC  

The workers create capital, the CEO takes credit for it

2017-06-13 23:15:36 UTC  

The pay increases are virtually non effective in relation to pay equality because the capitalist economy made it ineffective

2017-06-13 23:15:37 UTC  

Because those ceos make 300-500x as much as their workers on average