Message from @Zircuits

Discord ID: 430857659277901835


2018-04-03 22:20:22 UTC  

So it was ended, just not under lenin

2018-04-03 22:20:55 UTC  

Then it came back.

2018-04-03 22:21:25 UTC  

Hell, collectivization lasted shorter than capitalization by almost 100 years.

2018-04-03 22:22:41 UTC  

It led to the fall of the USSR and a rise in poverty

2018-04-03 22:23:38 UTC  

Poverty and starvation was it's worse under stalin actually.

2018-04-03 22:23:59 UTC  

But to be fair, that can be attributed to WW2...... for the most part.

2018-04-03 22:25:56 UTC  

Starvation can also be explained by the massive industrialization effort

2018-04-03 22:27:25 UTC  

Isn't that a reckless maneouver though? Europe managed to do it just fine without the mass starvation.....

2018-04-03 22:28:13 UTC  

Russia was a very backwards country at this time

2018-04-03 22:28:43 UTC  

It had famines all the time also, even before communism, as a result

2018-04-03 22:28:44 UTC  

Hell, it should have been much easier to do at that time, since technology had advanced by 40 years.

2018-04-03 22:28:56 UTC  

@ᵈˢʳ✪ But none so severe.

2018-04-03 22:32:59 UTC  

@ᵈˢʳ✪ True, but it only became worse under communism.

2018-04-03 22:33:21 UTC  

The soviet tried to solve it, but while undergoing a rapid industrialisation process

2018-04-03 22:33:31 UTC  

Of course they would have worsened

2018-04-03 22:33:39 UTC  

@ᵈˢʳ✪ And look at how it turned out.

2018-04-03 22:33:53 UTC  

Look at the Great Leap Forward in the PRC

2018-04-03 22:34:11 UTC  

@ᵈˢʳ✪ >Of course they would have worsened

2018-04-03 22:34:22 UTC  

are you sure it worsened?

2018-04-03 22:34:30 UTC  

After a civil war and a push for industrialization which led them to become one of the most powerful countries

2018-04-03 22:35:31 UTC  

@Zircuits Not really, they were inferior in everyway to the west, their only advantage was numbers and territory.

2018-04-03 22:35:45 UTC  

I think ww2 had a greater effect, though @Deleted User

2018-04-03 22:35:58 UTC  

I think we’re forgetting who did most of the fighting

2018-04-03 22:36:13 UTC  

Germany.

2018-04-03 22:36:18 UTC  

Kek

2018-04-03 22:36:24 UTC  

also the space race and the nuclear arms race

2018-04-03 22:36:36 UTC  

@ᵈˢʳ✪ That wasn't a joke.

2018-04-03 22:37:04 UTC  

@Zircuits We are talking about the 1920s.

2018-04-03 22:37:26 UTC  

Oh

2018-04-03 22:37:28 UTC  

Nuclear weapons were not even theorized yet.

2018-04-03 22:37:57 UTC  

industrialization played a huge role in their expansion into other fields

2018-04-03 22:38:09 UTC  

@Zircuits That it did.

2018-04-03 22:38:37 UTC  

And they did it so recklessly that millions starved, and went into poverty.

2018-04-03 22:42:52 UTC  

Also Russia lost WW1 remember

2018-04-03 22:44:00 UTC  
2018-04-03 22:45:34 UTC  

But the thing is that starvation only increased as more communist policies were enacted.

2018-04-03 22:47:53 UTC  

In my opinion, I think Russia moved to collectivisation too early

2018-04-03 22:48:23 UTC  

Lenin abandoned collectivization and allowed for capitalism.

2018-04-03 22:48:26 UTC  

Or maybe it was because the kulaks literally burnt their harvest so the soviets couldn't collectavize it.