Message from @Mr.Cactus

Discord ID: 506582167749656586


2018-10-29 21:34:15 UTC  

nah but like, what I was saying

Lol Pisslam won't conquer shit

2018-10-29 21:34:16 UTC  

900 iq logic

you've been declining since the Mongols raped Baghdad

2018-10-29 21:34:39 UTC  

Developed countries aren't ethnostates because people from 3rd world countries flood there

2018-10-29 21:34:42 UTC  

There's communists, fascists, liberals, conservatives,and just about every political position you can think of in France

2018-10-29 21:34:46 UTC  

and other similar nation states

2018-10-29 21:34:54 UTC  

I love how we get pinged for dumb shit

2018-10-29 21:34:57 UTC  

there's not really any core ideal

2018-10-29 21:35:03 UTC  

hell, culture varies quite a bit too

2018-10-29 21:35:08 UTC  

But nobody cares Merkel is not running for parliament in 2021

2018-10-29 21:35:13 UTC  

based on the city, various regional trends, and so on

2018-10-29 21:35:22 UTC  

even then, why about...

2018-10-29 21:35:29 UTC  

Strasbourg for instance?

2018-10-29 21:35:42 UTC  
2018-10-29 21:35:43 UTC  

Oi

2018-10-29 21:35:49 UTC  

I want to see japan invaded by muslims and Africans so the japan ethnostate meme can die

2018-10-29 21:35:49 UTC  

yes

2018-10-29 21:35:59 UTC  

We get pinged for dumb announcements

2018-10-29 21:36:06 UTC  

But not for Merkel

2018-10-29 21:36:40 UTC  

Hitler was a Jewish plant

2018-10-29 22:43:33 UTC  

lel

2018-10-29 22:46:55 UTC  

Hitler was a Syrian refugee

2018-10-29 22:55:22 UTC  

Hitler was a Syrian jew

2018-10-29 23:09:32 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/452955238186614794/506605536893206528/Screenshot_20181029-190911.png

2018-10-29 23:10:19 UTC  

let's keep it at this point,shall we?

2018-10-29 23:11:05 UTC  

seems that everyone agrees that a key factor is ethnicity,and this is a fair definition of it

2018-10-30 00:25:34 UTC  

No. I don't agree. The foundation of a nation state is its history. It cannot be its ethnicity otherwise there would be no imperialistoc nation state by definition.

2018-10-30 00:28:48 UTC  

There have been succesful cases of assimilation of places from many different backgrounds
ask the US for instance

2018-10-30 00:30:29 UTC  

It's been mostly for the settlement of Americans from other regions that populated what otherwise would've been wastelands

2018-10-30 00:32:31 UTC  

try to go the any of the states formed from the Lousiana purchase and spot ties to its french history outside of the names of the cities and flags

2018-10-30 00:33:12 UTC  

(and of course don't come here with New Orleans,that's more the exception than the rule)

2018-10-30 09:21:28 UTC  

If a state is a nation state that encompases multiple nations, that means it favour one nation.

2018-10-30 09:45:04 UTC  

There are very specific single culture dominant regions in a country, for example, Quebec in Canada, Utah in United States. Then there are communities of Asians, Arabs, Hispanics etc. spreading across several counties.

2018-10-30 12:20:41 UTC  

lol assimilation, you mean reducing your culture to consumerism? The US still to this day has massive pockets of unassimilated yet coexisting whites. Literally some cities are purely of a specific descent, german, finnish, swedish, polish etc. On the streets you speak english sure, but much of the local culture, and food, is literally ethnic. Brazil is another perfect example of, if you let cultures exist and dont replace them with comsumerism ou get brazil. Usually though you have a dominant culture that opresses (which it must necessarily) the minority cultures. Hell during my time in the US on the west coast ther eis no culture, its literally multikulti. I could appreciate asian, scandinavian, hispanic culture. But press me on what american culture is an I couldnt even really tell you from my experience living on the west coast (some 12 years there).

The principle foundation for the nation state, more often than not, is its people and their common cultural group. Generally the nation is well, an ethnicity a homogenous people with little variety between each other, the state exists to accumulate and focus the power nad will of this ethnicity. It is more a formalization and organization of this group. The nation state as such is founded upon its people and its specific cultural group, ergo ethnicity. Ethnicity means a cultural group which means a specific homogenous genetic group that then has a common culture and group identity.

2018-10-30 12:20:53 UTC  

the definition proposed by goodle is of course brutally filtered.

2018-10-30 12:21:04 UTC  

to exclude a genetic or ancenstral idea.

2018-10-30 12:21:15 UTC  

ethnicity mandates, because culture does as well, a common historical origin.

2018-10-30 12:21:22 UTC  

ergo genetic homogeneity.

2018-10-30 13:58:31 UTC  

@everyone Daily Question 🔖

Who would be a good replacement for Senate Majority leader, considering the GOP is most likely going to keep the Senate? Mitch McConnell doesn't have plans to resign or retire but if he does, who should take his place to lead the Senate?

2018-10-30 13:59:11 UTC  

Mikhail Gorbachev