America is not a democracy lmao

that's not what I asked

Its a constitutional republic

Well we're talking about America, so I'm pointing to American democracy.

We democratically elect people

<:HyperLmao:459545665517780993> >america is a democracy

that's it

And yes America absolutely is a democracy. Why is it not a democracy? Representative democracy makes a republic a republic. Did you ever stop for more than two seconds and wonder why it's called representative "democracy"?

Or did that just slip your mind?

what define a 'democracy'

''a democracy''

Rule by the people, etymologically speaking.

Demos, kratos.

america is ruled by [all] the people because we elect representatives?

Legally speaking America is a democracy even if it's been so heavily bureaucratized since FDR that the people increasingly have less power over the affairs of the state.

It doesn't suddenly stop being a democracy as soon as government isn't as small and direct as you want it to be. Sorry, that's not how the world works.

We still elect people, federally and locally.

Those people decide domestic and foreign policy.

''It doesn't suddenly stop being a democracy as soon as government isn't as small and direct as you want it to be. Sorry, that's not how the world works.'' I never implied that

When they don't do what we want as voters we don't reelect them.

Sounds like democracy to me.

Anon seems to have run off after claiming that America isn't a democracy for the 2946th time and being told why he's wrong by me on this specific point for the 2946th time.

the only say we have in their decisions is getting them elected. we can't guarantee that they'll do what the majority wants

Yes, but that doesn't make it not a democracy. A republic is a democracy.

we have a say in who gets in power, depending on the position, that's about it

it's not rule by the people

Don't want to rely on words too much here but America is legally a representative *democracy.* We call a system of government where people elect representatives a democracy because they vote, thereby influencing the public affairs (res public, public affair).

You're disagreeing with established definitions for God knows why.

But you're plain and simply wrong.

I think democracy is too broad

there's direct and rep, and god knows how many other forms

It's meant to be broad, that's why democracy can be representative or direct. Direct democracy is not the only type of democracy.

why are you so hostile <:HyperLmao:459545665517780993>

I didn't call you stupid, I just explained why you were wrong and then told you you were wrong.

''I didn't call you stupid'' whomst the fuck said you did

You called me hostile. I think I start being hostile when I start insulting you.

But I haven't insulted you.

If you're more sensitive than I am then that's none of my business.

you don't suddenly stop being hostile when the word isn't a simple and direct as you want it to be. Sorry, that's not how language works.

You successfully derailed the conversation. Next time I will avoid pointing out when you're wrong so I don't hurt your feelings.

I derailed the convo by asking why you were so hostile and giving you a dose of your own medicine