Message from @GermanEastAfrica

Discord ID: 452106573439827979


2018-06-01 13:46:43 UTC  

And in a certain sense so does fascism but we take in account the family and old culture

2018-06-01 13:46:59 UTC  

And the end results are different for both

2018-06-01 13:47:14 UTC  

That seems to be the most big divides i’ve seen

the issue here is that family and culture are not thngs we consider as part of the 'economic base' as in the material things that shape everything but as things that are shaped by our economic base.

2018-06-01 13:47:31 UTC  

I’m going to be honest I’ve learned quite a bit from talking with you folks

family may be family always

2018-06-01 13:48:00 UTC  

I see, you’re more focused on the straight shot economic values

but how family is conceived as an idea depends on how economics are at the time

we live in very nuclear families under capitalism

under say primitive communism/tribalism

they lived in less nuclear famlies

and more 'communal living'

2018-06-01 13:48:41 UTC  

I see

this was because communal living was better for the tribal setting

while nuclear family is better for the capitalist setting

this is ultimately what i mean when i say 'the base shapes the superstructure'

2018-06-01 13:49:25 UTC  

I believe it works well under a fascist system as well

2018-06-01 13:49:31 UTC  

And that’s why we value it

2018-06-01 13:50:06 UTC  

It’s also formed from the recent state of the family and how we see it falling apart under this current system which is leading to complications

2018-06-01 13:50:32 UTC  

Which I think helps the drive to protect the nuclear family idea

@GermanEastAfrica so what i want to say is that marxists are not against marriage or family as things people do
but the specific forms of marriage and family inherent to capitalism

2018-06-01 13:50:50 UTC  

@LoJ Wait for the Congress to convene

2018-06-01 13:50:58 UTC  

Like the fact you need a license for marriage

well more like marriage is a way for often men to control women

i.e in feudalistic times

marriage was all about

how can i obtain more land?

yes marry my daugthers off to the rich son of that landowner

2018-06-01 13:51:43 UTC  

Due to the fact that was the only way to have rights

so the very conception of marriage has shifted in society

due to the romanticist movement

marriage has been commodified as well

into the capitalist system

but because marriage still came from that feudalistic kind of thinking it still remains an reactionary element and only serves to hold certain groups down.

2018-06-01 13:52:48 UTC  

My view on marriage and the role of the mother is that it’s alright for the woman to get a job but she should not be shamed into never getting married

2018-06-01 13:53:22 UTC  

The owner rn is thinking about president's rights

@GermanEastAfrica the observation i've made of capitalist society is that we commodified marriage such that women are kinda shamed if they aren't married and have children.

2018-06-01 13:53:46 UTC  

I see things the opposite ways nowadays

2018-06-01 13:54:20 UTC  

Two different looks at the same mirror I suppose