Message from @Redneo

Discord ID: 481194620978593802


2018-08-20 20:09:18 UTC  

oh, rly?

2018-08-20 20:09:22 UTC  

The far right equivalent pof socialism would be plutocracy... which socialism often devolves into, but I mean intentionally

2018-08-20 20:09:23 UTC  

🤔

2018-08-20 20:09:33 UTC  

then how is the US not socialist and has been since public schools and the VA is a thing?^^

2018-08-20 20:09:50 UTC  

not in a pure sense, but in Europe you have parties considered "right wing" that are socialist

2018-08-20 20:09:58 UTC  

maybe that's why you are confusing things

2018-08-20 20:10:41 UTC  

Our public schools in germany arent socialist btw. The competition by private schools is not impeded on by our system. In the sense that they also receive a similar funding per student from the government to put them on equal footing.

2018-08-20 20:11:09 UTC  

you are the one bringing up schools though. No one here was talking about schools

2018-08-20 20:11:24 UTC  

Right

2018-08-20 20:11:25 UTC  

ouch, actually living in germany

2018-08-20 20:11:43 UTC  

I totally understand your point, if you live in Germany though

2018-08-20 20:11:57 UTC  

and unlike the VA, insurance policies paid by the state are not tied to paticular doctors.

2018-08-20 20:12:02 UTC  

also, very ironic that you think most of Europe doesn't tend to socialism

2018-08-20 20:12:29 UTC  

oh they're definitely headed that direction

2018-08-20 20:12:34 UTC  

but they're not actually socialist yet

2018-08-20 20:12:47 UTC  

or any more socialist than the US.

2018-08-20 20:12:58 UTC  

social programs are not socialist

2018-08-20 20:13:21 UTC  

in fact, social programs only make sense under capitalism

2018-08-20 20:14:18 UTC  

sorry to interrupt for a bit, but I really wanted an answer to this..
>if a group advocates for full authoritarianism, I call that fascism. Am I wrong?

2018-08-20 20:15:13 UTC  

well, originaly it described a certain italian party.

2018-08-20 20:15:37 UTC  

later it was used to describe all nationalistic, authoritarian and antimarxist movements

2018-08-20 20:15:45 UTC  

i think it may require an element of nationalism

2018-08-20 20:15:47 UTC  

I know, specially how innacurate wikipedia is about this

2018-08-20 20:16:12 UTC  

Antimarxist but also anticapitalist

2018-08-20 20:16:18 UTC  

@Tohob I agree, but wouldn't you say that full authoritarianism inherently has nacionalism?

2018-08-20 20:16:45 UTC  

@.B the EU disagrees

2018-08-20 20:17:10 UTC  

or rather, demonstrates that thats not quite correct

2018-08-20 20:17:35 UTC  

EU isn't even powerful enough to command one country directly

2018-08-20 20:17:43 UTC  

it is FAR from full authoritarianism

2018-08-20 20:17:56 UTC  

Fascism allows for more autonomy(in theory) than many other authoritarian systems, but not much more freedom. Your autonomy ends when you use it to further yourself rather than the interests of the country

2018-08-20 20:18:07 UTC  

you don't have much of a nation if people can flee from your orders

2018-08-20 20:18:17 UTC  

do you actualy have to have the power to do what you want in order to be authoritarian though?

2018-08-20 20:19:15 UTC  

In other words, was hitler not authoritarian prior to 1933? (assuming for the sake of argument his views didnt change)

2018-08-20 20:20:19 UTC  

pretty much

2018-08-20 20:20:31 UTC  

he could be authoritarian

2018-08-20 20:20:43 UTC  

but he didn't have the power to exercise his views

2018-08-20 20:22:02 UTC  

@Schedrevka I agree with what you said. Most of Europe was fascist if you consider it that way, and that's why it rose above others. But my question remains, if a group advocates for full authoritarianism, isn't it always Fascism?

2018-08-20 20:23:17 UTC  

they command all the countries directly, local cops have to enforce eu laws

2018-08-20 20:23:57 UTC  

they control the laws but not how they are applied

2018-08-20 20:24:13 UTC  

there's a lot of room for "rebelion" and interpretation of the law

2018-08-20 20:24:27 UTC  

I'm not disagreeing that EU is authoritarian