If I speak jew a thousand times

Economics will go away

Yes yes, well it is a foregone conclusion that if you were going to be a high up official in the Soviet government you had to collaborate with Jewish intellectuals and administrators.

See?

They were the de facto ruling class.

Iron logic

I can see that you simply don't want to discuss this.

It's da joos

I wonder why...

Because you don't provide sources or proof

Just repeat the Jews or jewish

Of course I don't have patience for that

I'm not a pol fag

If you want to say jew every single damn phrase and every single damn statement just go for one of your circlejerks

Yeah

Because whether @comuna redpill realises it he is more predisposed to communism because of his ethnic interest.

LMAO

I'm poor and Brazilian

I'm no George Soros

The thing is not every single jew is a nation leader

In fact the majority are proletarians

Communism isn't ethnic based

It deceives with that lie in theory, but in practice it is dispelled.

Plus "members of the bolshevik central government" can be interpreted in many ways

The politburo

The sovnarkom

The supreme soviet

The party comitee

@Deleted User oh a oppressed minority in Russia was politically active

Especially after several pogroms

Geez those jews

What a damn surprise

They can't even get murdered and stay quiet

Without them Bolshevism as we know it would have never taken root in Russia.

You would be surprised as it would

But Jewish cadres helped a lot

It would be replaced by some other populist movement, but that a big "if" in the first place. The Jews have had a long history in Europe, and not for the better.

Because they suffered heavy oppression

Lmao

Just keep saying the jews

All the problems will go away

Dont look at your working rights too

Oh and the working class in other nations is not your problem

No, NO GOY! DON'T CALL ATTENTION TO US! We have your best interests at heart!

Not all Jews of course

But it doesn't boil down to race

Stupid goy, read some Marxist literature.

Yep

It would make some good for you

Get that bourgeois propaganda out of your head

Plus psych Hitler was a rotschild

"bourgeois propaganda" - this is the thing with you commies and capitalists, you are always stuck in this false paradigm of left and right.

Hahahaha

To the left the Third Position is capitalism, to the right it's Communism.

You simply refuse to comprehend it.

As if the bourgeoisie only stayed in the right

You are stupid as hell mate

You think that you are above those questions

hmmm that's what people usually say when they have nothing constructive to say 🤔

When you are just a cheap ass bourgeois apologist

The bourgeoisie has several movements on the left

Dengism

Social democracy

Mutualism

And so on

And your ideology fits their narrative too

Your discourse is a well known one

Used for centuries to deviate the proletariat from their road to power

Well for a few hundred years to be more exact

Plus you think your statements were constructive and not cheap propaganda I have heard before?

That's quite an ego we have here

Specially if put in front with your actual capacity of quoting properly

Or as you would say

Jewish trickery

You said you were part Jewish, I'm suspecting that's at least half by now. Otherwise you would not be so dedicatedly rhetorical and duplicitous.

LMAO

as if I need to be from one race to despise racism against it

I'm not you

lol you write a wall of shit and you expect me to counter every single thing you asserted,

Of course I do

I'm arguing

I'm dedicated rethorically because it's a part of being a communist

And I'm bad at it

A debate only really goes somewhere if it's on first principles and one thing at a time, otherwise there is a great chance for the dialogue to be disingenuous and mocking in nature as we see here.

Even if I didn't had jew ancestry I would argue the same way

i doubt it

@Deleted User mate you are just calling me a jew several times

I have to mock you

@Deleted User many non Jews do that

Stalin advocated death penalty for anti semites

Lmao

I agree with comuna, does that mean I have hidden jewish ancestry?

Here he goes

you are only using laughter to placate yourself from introspection.

Man you talk as your discourse was the last biscuit in the package

I heard that so many times

It's not deep or insight inducting

It's cheap and rotten propaganda

I have the right as a human being to laugh at that

And for the lack of introspection blame your repetitive shitty writing

I mean at least in mein kampf the small moustache manlet had a bit of charisma

@Deleted User also good goy take a shekel

*rubs hands sneakily*

Capitalism and Communism = Two sides of the same coin

It also confuses association with causation, which fuels the reliance on conspiracy.

@Deleted User it's all the Jews

Don't look at your paycheck

And if you have debt it's because of the Jews anyway

both capitalism and communism are Jewish I'm so smart

Apparently, the Third Position does not have a 'ruling elite'.

I'm totally not a capital apologist

@Deleted User they have their beloved national bourgeoisie

If they don't have the big nose it's ok

Nah too scientific

Let's drawn on romantism

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn964fnabmk

trump supporters theme song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FvzMY-zo0Q

yeah

i was aslo in operation blueism's stream

http://thehill.com/media/400049-chinese-professor-removed-by-police-during-live-interview-report

imagine liking the color green better than red in china and having the police show up to your door and arrest you

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/ethnic-cleansing-makes-a-comeback--in-china/2018/08/02/55f73fa2-9691-11e8-810c-5fa705927d54_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.3b14b12fd68e

imagine being an ethnic minority in china and being imprisoned for doing nothing

i know "china isn't communist" but this kind of shit isn't ok

Spoiled millenial liberals probably dont care

Hi

true

Wut

And which human rights violations

@BigBadRed9000

Eh nah

That’s the government not the people

Government is more dangerous

@Brickiest Brick I hate china

They are the us with a red banner

Tiny brain, Democrats are shitlibs lmao they're not left

Yeah

Center right to right

>commies

>having brain

commies dont do brain stuff

haha omega funny

I thought it was

@ApplicationBot I like her. Wouldnt say shes 100% right of course but smart and right at alot

she was just a rip off and weird nietzsche with some stirner mixed in

claiming romantism and objectivism at the same time lmao

Nietzsche and stirner mixed in sounds good

sounds idealist as hell

Humans arent naturally realists and materialists. JP has explained this pretty well.

I like idealism

it makes Art mean something

materialism is inherently human not the other way around

I wouldnt say Nietzsche or stiner is idealist though

its how humans perceive reality

art means something

the aesthetic represantation of the social sein and dasein

Not at all, if that was the case we wouldn't have gods for a very good majority of our pasts

you have to beare in mind that cult value can have material reasons

Sein and dasein?

They can but they're not 100% materialist

being and coming-into-being at a more or less bad translation

not in ther appearence

religion came as a institution to regulate social behaviour

and after some time restricted pratices such as canibalism and poligamy

And they believed in magical dieties still

because of property relations

they did because they couldnt understand or show the real process because alienation is inherent to cult value

we need to look deeper than the appearence to get to the religious real content

Christians arent being alienated

they are in many ways

Such as?

religion is inherent alieantion

such as lets say

the passages about sodom and gomorrah

Give an example for the average christian

God is omnipotent and oniscient while being all knowning

thats logically impossible

Right but they believe it because they dont think it is

while being "good"

@Mr. X exactly

alienation

How's that alienation?

they are alienated from the logical fallacy that this represents

Lacking knowledge isnt alienation

as even questioning is looked like a "bad attitude" in religion

@Mr. X it can be if its institutionalized

Used to for sure, not as much now though

and the church is a institution as long as i know

They werent controlling the lack of knowledge

it was the same as thinking the earth was not in the centre of the universe

they simply didnt know

in the religious field? for many they do

I highly doubt that now

many religious cadres have a good enough education to know those things

not the followers of the faith though

How do you think Atheism became more and more of a thing out of christianity?

and thats where alienation comes in

because capitalism needs at least a partial dismantling of those institutions

as the bible has a lot of feudal ideology

such as separatism on the roman empire and so on

So how would atheism benefit capitalism?

not necessarily atheism

but restricted religion

Such as?

and specially stronger on the masses

like people not using religion in science

as a method

Religion in science? What religious method has been used in science?

or taking religion as a coexhistent being with reason

In places in the west?

@Mr. X feudal times

Oh

thomas aquinas

and so on

many of the feudal technicians and specialists came from the clergy

and their visions were essentialy linked to religion

As they were the most educated in such fields right?

yep as the clergy had a important role on maintaining the feudal status quo

with concepts such as divine right

that were when not destroyed modified

such as in the french revolution

How would capitalism be the cause of atheism being more popular exactly though?

because in its essence capitalism is atheistic lets say

its about the commodities and not the institutions around it

but they have a need for maintaining those institutions with some restrictions

in order to contain conscience specially on the masses

and in many pseudo intelectual areas

and as capitalism expands the contradictions between the necessities of capital and those institutions grow larger

So the scientific method became better due to capitalism aswell as the education as time past?

Hence why people started being atheists?

in relation to feudalism? a billion times better

but atheism can be contained too

for example positivism

they essentially are for the most atheists

but they are cointaned in the small crate of formal logic

And what is positivism exactly?

its the theory created by theorists such as comte and durkheim

What's the theory?

its basically based on positive affirmations

Im not familiar with Comte or Durkheim

or formal logic

such as

all red crayons are red