Message from @ETBrooD

Discord ID: 691832353785643070


2020-03-24 02:09:02 UTC  

You've obviously never read him and obviously don't know what you're talking about. He's still widely taught and respected in and by modern psychology.

2020-03-24 02:09:53 UTC  

You don't even have the slightest inkling of psychology, let alone in a modern sense

2020-03-24 02:10:10 UTC  

Well, psychology isn't a pure science by any metric. However freud was far more scientific minded than most modern psychologists, vast majority of whom do not actually use psychoanalysis. The field is sorta dead tbh.

2020-03-24 02:11:05 UTC  

> You don't even have the slightest inkling of psychology, let alone in a modern sense
@Hexidecimark I've ***literally*** been studying it since I was a child, but okay rere, whatever you say.

2020-03-24 02:11:19 UTC  

Freud was wrong on a lot of things

2020-03-24 02:11:28 UTC  

Try reading a book by freud. @Hexidecimark

2020-03-24 02:11:44 UTC  

@ETBrooD Everyone is.

2020-03-24 02:11:50 UTC  

Eh, no

2020-03-24 02:11:54 UTC  

I've read more of Jung

2020-03-24 02:12:07 UTC  

Einstein was mostly right. Freud was very often wrong. And the list of his mistakes is only increasing, Einstein's is not.

2020-03-24 02:12:41 UTC  

Are you even serious? Einstein was wrong about a lot of stuff <:pepelaugh:544857300179877898>

2020-03-24 02:12:56 UTC  

the fuck

2020-03-24 02:13:04 UTC  

Ever heard of space time? Literally a nonsensical theory.

2020-03-24 02:13:14 UTC  

One example? You said "a lot"

2020-03-24 02:13:28 UTC  

Well he didn't actually do that much

2020-03-24 02:13:31 UTC  

Freud was wrong on one of his most central concepts

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/680587502918041623/691832034007580735/freud-psychosexual2.png

2020-03-24 02:13:42 UTC  

Some of his previously thought wrong ideas also come back later being considered right again

2020-03-24 02:13:45 UTC  

Space time was one of his big things

2020-03-24 02:14:04 UTC  

@ETBrooD Can you give an example of something freud was wrong about?

2020-03-24 02:14:36 UTC  

I think a good way to put it is that Freud was explanatory but he's not scientific because he never tried to be predictive.

2020-03-24 02:14:46 UTC  

Freud thought that if you accidentally say a word that you didn't mean to say, it reveals something about your true self

2020-03-24 02:15:09 UTC  

> I think a good way to put it is that Freud was explanatory but he's not scientific because he never tried to be predictive.
@Hexidecimark Says the person who I seriously doubt has read any freud

2020-03-24 02:15:44 UTC  

> Freud thought that if you accidentally say a word that you didn't mean to say, it reveals something about your true self
@ETBrooD That's a real thing though. It isn't always true but sometimes it is.

2020-03-24 02:16:01 UTC  

Freudian slips are definitely real.... <:pepelaugh:544857300179877898>

2020-03-24 02:16:02 UTC  

It's a BS theory, because it can't be proven.

2020-03-24 02:16:05 UTC  

I've read him in several psych classes, he's not someone who ends up being terribly practical to read

2020-03-24 02:16:26 UTC  

Like I said I've done more with Jung

2020-03-24 02:16:30 UTC  

No theory in psychology can really be proven

2020-03-24 02:16:32 UTC  

Freudian slips are not valid, they're statistical anomalies that are normal and are supposed to happen.

2020-03-24 02:17:15 UTC  

I'm 100% sure that they're real, but whatever man

2020-03-24 02:17:21 UTC  

If nothing in psychology can be proven, then psychology is not science

2020-03-24 02:17:34 UTC  

You're telling me you've never had a Freudian slip? <:WaitWhatArmy:590858815189024778>

2020-03-24 02:17:40 UTC  

Not once in my entire life

2020-03-24 02:17:50 UTC  

@ETBrooD That's not how science works

2020-03-24 02:18:15 UTC  

Yes that is how it works. A theory that can't be proven is not a scientific theory. Falsification is *neccessary* for a scientific theory.

2020-03-24 02:18:55 UTC  

"science" in this context is synonymous with the scientific method. It does not require proof

2020-03-24 02:19:18 UTC  

Are you trolling me?

2020-03-24 02:19:24 UTC  

The scientific method is designed to generate proof my dude

2020-03-24 02:20:37 UTC  

LOL

2020-03-24 02:20:53 UTC  

Phad just posted an infographic that contradicts his claim

2020-03-24 02:20:54 UTC  

This is science

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/680587502918041623/691833894453903462/Screenshot_2020-03-23-21-20-36-016_com.brave.browser.png