Message from @Coochie coo
Discord ID: 528038897607901228
well, what if there is some other reason other than intending harm?
can u think of one
idk, maybe u got a song stuck in yoru head
maybe you got tourrett's
lmfao
i think I've made my point clear now
that is so ridiculous I will not entertain that
y is that ridiculous?
what's ridiculous is assuming intent
løgner @exaudi632 jesus elsker
Ah, yes, I had a song stuck in my head mr. judge, that is why I yelled fire. Please don't punish me.
heck, maybe you didn't know and your friends dared you to, there's a ton of reasons
I think we took the conversation to it's conclusion
sure, you think that actions in themselves have an assigned intent. I think differently.
Paradox, I can believe it isn't intentional to cause harm if it's a six year old. but an adult is a different story
I'm sure you have already, but have you talked to any VW bus clubs? I use to own a 1967 vw bus and they are very customizable, just a thought @Timcast
even then, why are people solely believing a 6 yo is beyond me
I don't think that actions have defined intent, but they do have defined consequences
if you yell fire in a crowd, someone will panic
not convinced all people are that stupid
No, but I think there is reasonable evidence to assume intent, in this case. That is how our courts work though. It isn't perfect.
in which case?
The case of yelling fire in a crowded area.
i haven't assumed intent, i thought that's what we were discussing
and i was disagreeing
you haven't, hiniku is saying that there may be reasonable evidence in the case of yelling fire in a theatre
to convince a court of malicious intent
which is why i am a free speech absolutist, like i said at the beginning, according ot tim's definition.
I think there might be some miscommunication, when did I say you were agreeing?
oh was that an appeal to authority?
How about this Paradox
i was disagreeing with that.
Let's see if we can agree on this
too
If someone has malicious intent to hurt people and yells fire in a crowded theatre, should they be punished?
nope
what?
I think that if your actions cause physical harm to another person, whether your actions were physical or verbal, you deserve punishment. I'm a consequentialist
because yelling fire doesn't hurt people
Ok, well, that is stupid.