Message from @SYDWAD
Discord ID: 602465746727206913
or look at google, they are basically a country
now
they even have armed land the local government cant enter.
"you need a government to stop people from gaining too much power"
1) this is incredibly vague
2) what does it have to do with communism
I don't think you understand communism, in a communist system you cannot 'become too powerful' as the means of production would be available for all to milk
ok, how will the system stay equal and distribute the resources without a government of some kind?
3 ways
What do you mean by "equal"
3 ways?
Centralised planning through artificial intelligence (perhaps with the demands of the people in mind democratically) is a cool option
*laissez faire* communism π workplaces simply starting their means of production because they simply want to produce the product of their desire
I kid when I say 3 ways, in reality there are many ways
that involve central planning, decentralised planning, human interaction, ai involvement, mixed, etc.
The point is it can exist without a government and I think what you're concerned with is a state, and it can exist without a coercive state
thats still just a government, a form of overarching governance
How well do you know Ancapism
i mean if you define a government as any kind of administrative apparatus then sure
is Ancapism necessarily anti-government?
but in that case a society without a government is impossible
Ancap has been anti-*state* with the most die hard wanting decentralisation of public goods through private businesses
however ancaps haven't been against the concept of governance
most i know is a perosn telling me it was the same as ancapitalisum with a general public idea keeping things equal through something
hence why you see voluntaryist governance advocates
No
I claim that you may be conflating state and government
and that government is simply a service provider
whilst a state is a government that is coercive in nature
some ancaps take it further wanting the decentralisation of this service provider so that it can get the benefits of free market competition
and so that it's power isn't centralised
and voting with bux means no voting with ballot so you have companies
actually can you screen cap this for tomorrow? we've been at this for almost two hours, its almost 5am and i actually cant see straight
Sure, how much would you like me to screen cap?
after "3 ways"
.
alright well cya later mate
if you ever want to continue just tag me
Communists commentating on anarcho-capitalism is always infuriating
Its always just strawman and smear campaigns
βHey look at this rothbard quote taken out of context from the 70s.β
Those wacky pedo rapist murderer right wingers am I right
Lets just forget the very real, albeit exaggerated, rapes by the red army of children and women in Germany
Or the very real failures of any and all ancoms