Message from @zoopokemon

Discord ID: 401608564596015105


2018-01-13 05:09:05 UTC  

But instead it’s a 8 year old boy crossdressing giving lap dances to old men

2018-01-13 05:09:16 UTC  

You don’t have to align with everything liberal

2018-01-13 05:09:37 UTC  

Yes. I suppose that is the liberal way but we aren’t right on everything

2018-01-13 05:09:50 UTC  

No Apotheosis, because he will be an individal so parents can do just anything

2018-01-13 05:10:06 UTC  

By that logic, the liberal thing to do would be to not interfere with slave owners' affairs.

2018-01-13 05:10:24 UTC  

good point, it's about the child's liberation

2018-01-13 05:12:36 UTC  

but on what grounds is this bad way of raising the child? Is it more liberating for the parents to be raising them as they see fit, is it more liberating to let the child do what he wants, or is it more liberating for the state to intervene when necessary?

2018-01-13 05:12:54 UTC  

doesn't this entirely depend on a separate moral judgement than what is "liberating"

2018-01-13 05:13:16 UTC  

isn't it what is good for the self, family, and society in a particular balance what is ultimately important??

2018-01-13 05:16:08 UTC  

and wanting to push your idea of "good," instead of leaving people as they are in a state such as this is anything but "liberal" but is the moral thing to do?

2018-01-13 05:16:26 UTC  

What is important is what is liberating for the indidual, while yes kids are not yet individual are there for tecnicly the property of the parents, but since kids eventaly become individals people should not interfer with that procces, killing, abuse, exc.

2018-01-13 05:17:39 UTC  

ah, so it is a particular process of raising children that you want to enforce. at least, it is bounded where this in particular is out of bounds

2018-01-13 05:19:56 UTC  

they must be raised in such a way that they become an "individual"

2018-01-13 05:21:43 UTC  

makes sense

2018-01-13 05:22:57 UTC  

under the classical liberal ideology it makes sense to recommend children be raised in such a way that they become capable members of a classical liberal society and will champion your ideals

2018-01-13 05:23:12 UTC  

but is that not enforcing your values onto a collective?

2018-01-13 05:24:35 UTC  

I don't think rasing children to be free will make them want freedom necessary.

2018-01-13 05:26:14 UTC  

I just don't think you can only take individual rights into some kind of calculus without appealing to some kind of societal (collective) good

2018-01-13 05:26:47 UTC  

tricky situations like this, with families and children, expose this

2018-01-13 05:28:18 UTC  

classical liberalism tends to abstract people away into atomized individuals with no past, group associations (like one's family) and no duties or obligations to those groups

2018-01-13 05:29:03 UTC  

Well, yes. People don't allways follow those groups

2018-01-13 05:29:06 UTC  

but we are all part of families and it's by no means a trivial case

2018-01-13 05:30:05 UTC  

well, we wouldn't want people tyranized by their group, right?

2018-01-13 05:30:13 UTC  

except

2018-01-13 05:30:34 UTC  

this kid could use a little tyranizing don't you think?

2018-01-13 05:30:55 UTC  

in a direction that is positive for his personal growth

2018-01-13 05:31:01 UTC  

rather than the trajectory he is on

2018-01-13 05:34:23 UTC  

Because kids can't make individual judgments, while adults can (some exceptions).

2018-01-13 05:34:47 UTC  

Leave kids to the wolves then?

2018-01-13 05:36:59 UTC  

Their parents as individuals can make those judgments for them? True, but on what grounds is this a bad judgment made for him? What stops his best direction of "personal growth" being becoming the best boy-tranny ever?

2018-01-13 05:37:37 UTC  

He's performing sexualized acts for the enjoyment of adults.

2018-01-13 05:37:59 UTC  

So, it's societal intervention

2018-01-13 05:38:01 UTC  

That's not normal behavior for kids.

2018-01-13 05:38:23 UTC  

Why don't we let pedos have sex with kids?

2018-01-13 05:39:13 UTC  

Why don't we let people have slaves?

2018-01-13 05:39:29 UTC  

You tell me, aren't we violating individual rights here? what if the child consents? (I'm being facetious)

2018-01-13 05:39:59 UTC  

how does individualism address the rights of children

2018-01-13 05:41:00 UTC  

What about the rights of hospitalized people that are unconscious?

2018-01-13 05:41:08 UTC  

huh?

2018-01-13 05:41:29 UTC  

If I take advantage of a person that's unconscious, is that bad?

2018-01-13 05:42:12 UTC  

Say, raping an unconscious person.