Message from @Banjod
Discord ID: 642613630076190721
@Billy Ray gym e-thot being put in check
@glamp I do not like most of the arguments. Though, 1. is entertaining.
sorry duck but physics has to bend the knee to metaphysics
the five arguments feel like they were written by a bright kindergartener
science doesn't disprove god though
theyre not very compelling
you havent interacted with the real ones, only caricatures
yes, but i have quantum metaphysics
I find 1. compelling so far. I read Richard Carrier's criticism and was not swayed.
plus there is the passing down of knowledge through religion that could help adherents retain culture, and moral ideas throughout all of time, despite of the situation.
1. is first mover
thats brainlet tier
I read Richard Carrier's critique and was unconvinced.
i would bet 1000 dollars you've only heard the strawman version of the argument from motion
write them all
in a sentence
1. first mover
2.?
was banjod
the first mover?
but dont you know that argument?
yea ive been thinking about how most gods ever conceived are intrinsically tied to genesis
its interesting
Unmoved Mover is necessary
In one form or another
and i wonder if thats a first order condition
yes so almost all gods are based on fallacious reasoning
Sorta, Ed Feser's argument has 42 premises, so I do not know it by heart.
its almost comical
Great flood = ice caps melting, fast
no
Fug, you'd be able to make a better argument if you still were operating in an eternal Universe, but physics shows up the Universe had a beginning
our small part of it had a beginning
Shoots holes in whatever approach to an uncreated universe you might put forward
noah's flood was a local flood that took place on the arabian peninsula about 13k years ago
the beginning was actually a symmetry breaking
The flood didn't happen. Someone wrote a book on it. The writer's did not mean for people to conceptualize it as real. @Deleted User let me post a good video one it.
just a state change like ice melting
something existed before then
Symmetry breaking in what?
the higgs field