Message from @Mozalbete ⳩

Discord ID: 515862543244197899


2018-11-24 12:09:38 UTC  

Something coming from the Church fathers is not an authority, since there were heretical Church Fathers

2018-11-24 12:09:56 UTC  

In the Early church, you have either Peter or his successors as final authority

2018-11-24 12:10:04 UTC  

That is, those who have the final word

2018-11-24 12:10:12 UTC  

It seems that you think, as I have mentioned earlies

2018-11-24 12:10:25 UTC  

That there is some magical year from which there are no authoritative statements

2018-11-24 12:10:31 UTC  

Can you tell us exactly what year and why?

2018-11-24 12:10:37 UTC  

Is it the year 300? 400? 401?

2018-11-24 12:11:07 UTC  

So the filioque doesn't come from the scriptures. It doesn't come from the Fathers. So, from where?

2018-11-24 12:11:24 UTC  

Only the Roman Church?

2018-11-24 12:11:25 UTC  

What does it mean that "it comes from the Scriptures"?

2018-11-24 12:11:41 UTC  

are you aware of where the consideration of something as Scripture comes from?

2018-11-24 12:11:45 UTC  

Are you a former protestant?

2018-11-24 12:12:02 UTC  

Are you aware that being a Father of the Church doesn't make what you say authoritative?

2018-11-24 12:12:29 UTC  

So what is authoritative according to the Roman Church ?

2018-11-24 12:12:53 UTC  

Not the scriptures, not the Fathers

2018-11-24 12:12:57 UTC  

So what?

2018-11-24 12:12:57 UTC  

What Christ declared to be Authoritative

2018-11-24 12:13:06 UTC  

Not any "Bible" or "Fathers"

2018-11-24 12:13:08 UTC  

But the Church

2018-11-24 12:13:27 UTC  

Because as you show now, there are heretical Fathers of the Church

2018-11-24 12:13:34 UTC  

It seems you love the words "Fathers"

2018-11-24 12:13:37 UTC  

No.

2018-11-24 12:13:37 UTC  

And hate "of the Church"

2018-11-24 12:14:18 UTC  

You have a list of authoritative Fathers who aren't heretical. @Mozalbete ⳩

2018-11-24 12:14:25 UTC  

So we agree the filioque isn't rooted in the Early Church. It comes exclusively from the Roman Church?

2018-11-24 12:15:07 UTC  

The papal primacy is off topic

2018-11-24 12:15:26 UTC  

The moment you say "Fathers who aren't heretical", you concede that being a Father does not give you authority

2018-11-24 12:15:35 UTC  

The Filioque is true you want it or not

2018-11-24 12:15:46 UTC  

There is no rejection of it

2018-11-24 12:15:49 UTC  

Great debate thanks

2018-11-24 12:16:03 UTC  

High level, it's impressive 😂

2018-11-24 12:16:15 UTC  

You remind me of muslims who talk about how there is no trinity in the early Church

2018-11-24 12:16:21 UTC  

"That's the truth because it's the truth"

2018-11-24 12:16:27 UTC  

I'm amazed

2018-11-24 12:16:35 UTC  

It's the truth because it is declared as such by the Church of Christ

2018-11-24 12:16:55 UTC  

According to the Roman Church only

2018-11-24 12:17:06 UTC  

According to the one with primacy that has the final word

2018-11-24 12:17:29 UTC  

The one with an actual theological tradition

2018-11-24 12:17:58 UTC  

It is funny, though, to see the ones who brag about how much they hate scholastics trying to give theological arguments against masters of theology, with petty arguments that remind of protestants and muslims

2018-11-24 12:19:35 UTC  

Yes the papal primacy is the final resort to everything, even for the primal papacy itself.

2018-11-24 12:20:08 UTC  

The papal primacy is true because the Pope have the primacy @Lao Tseu Takedown. Didn't you know that ?