Message from @windmill man

Discord ID: 528537720318853121


2018-12-29 11:37:14 UTC  

What am I acting?

2018-12-29 11:37:15 UTC  

wrong screen cap

2018-12-29 11:37:26 UTC  

no because your brain isnt even making a decision

2018-12-29 11:37:29 UTC  

its just acting

2018-12-29 11:37:30 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/526921073397071892/528537042506874900/unknown.png

2018-12-29 11:37:33 UTC  

acting what?

2018-12-29 11:37:43 UTC  

?

2018-12-29 11:37:46 UTC  

just acting

2018-12-29 11:37:57 UTC  

Acting what?

2018-12-29 11:38:03 UTC  

What is it acting?

2018-12-29 11:38:22 UTC  

it means that your brain is simply taking action without any true sense of choice

2018-12-29 11:38:37 UTC  

I will provide a counter argument for this

2018-12-29 11:38:43 UTC  

you are breathing right now I will assume

2018-12-29 11:38:48 UTC  

yes

2018-12-29 11:38:52 UTC  

normally you do not think about breathing

2018-12-29 11:38:57 UTC  

sure

2018-12-29 11:39:00 UTC  

it is done automatically

2018-12-29 11:39:16 UTC  

sure

2018-12-29 11:39:47 UTC  

but thinking just denotes awareness of my internal processes

2018-12-29 11:40:07 UTC  

my point is, that as soon as you become aware of your internal processes you can change them

2018-12-29 11:40:12 UTC  

People can breath in 2 ways

2018-12-29 11:40:26 UTC  

either through your belly or through your chest

2018-12-29 11:40:41 UTC  

except you cant just "change them"

2018-12-29 11:40:46 UTC  

If you move your hand on your chest and take a deep breath you will after that automatically keep breathing through your chest and visa verca

2018-12-29 11:40:48 UTC  

you can try it

2018-12-29 11:41:15 UTC  

if there is a change is was predetermined by previous stimuli

2018-12-29 11:41:24 UTC  

What previous stimuli?

2018-12-29 11:41:33 UTC  

any and all

2018-12-29 11:41:55 UTC  

But isn't that the base of science

2018-12-29 11:42:00 UTC  

That everything has a reason for it

2018-12-29 11:42:21 UTC  

People always act out of reason unless they have a mental disease, does that mean you do not have free will?

2018-12-29 11:43:29 UTC  

those with mental diseases still act based on a previous reason

2018-12-29 11:43:39 UTC  

Alright, sure

2018-12-29 11:43:49 UTC  

So everyone acts out of reason

2018-12-29 11:43:57 UTC  

Does that mean nobody has free will?

2018-12-29 11:44:01 UTC  

lets clearly define reason

2018-12-29 11:44:02 UTC  

Because they go for the best choice?

2018-12-29 11:44:17 UTC  

reason as in the intial cause responsible for consequential effects

2018-12-29 11:44:26 UTC  

the cause of an event or situation or something that provides an excuse or explanation:

2018-12-29 11:44:32 UTC  

"best choice" is just a normative claim

2018-12-29 11:44:41 UTC  

Yes, because it is subjective