Message from @windmill man
Discord ID: 528537699548790784
But if I am my brain, I am making the decision am I not ?
What am I acting?
wrong screen cap
no because your brain isnt even making a decision
its just acting
acting what?
?
just acting
Acting what?
What is it acting?
it means that your brain is simply taking action without any true sense of choice
I will provide a counter argument for this
you are breathing right now I will assume
yes
normally you do not think about breathing
sure
it is done automatically
sure
but thinking just denotes awareness of my internal processes
People can breath in 2 ways
either through your belly or through your chest
except you cant just "change them"
If you move your hand on your chest and take a deep breath you will after that automatically keep breathing through your chest and visa verca
you can try it
if there is a change is was predetermined by previous stimuli
What previous stimuli?
any and all
But isn't that the base of science
That everything has a reason for it
People always act out of reason unless they have a mental disease, does that mean you do not have free will?
those with mental diseases still act based on a previous reason
Alright, sure
So everyone acts out of reason
Does that mean nobody has free will?
lets clearly define reason
Because they go for the best choice?
reason as in the intial cause responsible for consequential effects
the cause of an event or situation or something that provides an excuse or explanation:
"best choice" is just a normative claim