Message from @Deleted User

Discord ID: 350918685676011521


2017-08-26 08:22:28 UTC  

I mean

2017-08-26 08:23:05 UTC  

A certain amount of "common sense" is evolutionary due to human being pack animals

2017-08-26 08:23:09 UTC  

Hunger is a subjective expression of the need for an organism to consume energy to survive. Ethics is a modern invention.

2017-08-26 08:23:19 UTC  

It's entirely naturalistic in nature

2017-08-26 08:23:31 UTC  

So no ethcis in prehistorical humans then?

2017-08-26 08:23:40 UTC  

None even in classical times?

2017-08-26 08:23:48 UTC  

None in the middle ages? How recent is the concept?

2017-08-26 08:23:54 UTC  

Well, they had some cultural values, but they are not uniform.

2017-08-26 08:24:08 UTC  

I'd say the Greeks started it.

2017-08-26 08:24:10 UTC  

Studies on higher apes shows this is already present in their species to a certain extent

2017-08-26 08:24:21 UTC  

But not in clear continuation.

2017-08-26 08:24:23 UTC  

It's way older than homo sapiens

2017-08-26 08:24:33 UTC  

Yeah, it's way older.

2017-08-26 08:24:39 UTC  

As is hunger.

2017-08-26 08:24:48 UTC  

Even though the way we feel hunger has evolved over time.

2017-08-26 08:24:49 UTC  

There are many time since Greek idealism and now which were not ethical. Even 100 years ago there was hardly 'ethics'.

2017-08-26 08:25:05 UTC  

I think you're conflating ethics with social norms just a tad.

2017-08-26 08:25:16 UTC  

Well, define ethics.

2017-08-26 08:25:24 UTC  

It's just a social norm in my view.

2017-08-26 08:25:26 UTC  

Being nice n sheeit?

2017-08-26 08:25:34 UTC  

Not hurting others.

2017-08-26 08:25:41 UTC  

Caring for other people.

2017-08-26 08:25:49 UTC  

So where has humanity done that?

2017-08-26 08:25:53 UTC  

Fucking never.

2017-08-26 08:26:07 UTC  

All the time. But there are always the amoral and the immoral.

2017-08-26 08:26:12 UTC  

Always predators among us.

2017-08-26 08:26:15 UTC  

Predators and parasites.

2017-08-26 08:26:46 UTC  

I'm afraid it's not the exception.

2017-08-26 08:26:51 UTC  

@discordian#3213 You should note, that humanity has been sentient for (Roughly) 50K years.

2017-08-26 08:27:08 UTC  

But what I mean is that a bundle of pre-wired responses that evolved to allow small packs of humans to better survive together, while useful, can't be held as some sort of supreme ethics all humans have to bow down to

2017-08-26 08:27:13 UTC  

Yeah, depending how you define sentient it could go back much further.

2017-08-26 08:27:41 UTC  

I am speaking about homosapiens, the ones that roam the earth now.

2017-08-26 08:28:17 UTC  

Even australopithecines were capable of at least rudimentary morality though.

2017-08-26 08:28:34 UTC  

So it's been with us as long as we were Homo sapiens, wherever exactly that line is drawn.

2017-08-26 08:28:37 UTC  

Million of years.

2017-08-26 08:28:56 UTC  

>capable of at least rudimentary morality though
>ethics
Fuck off with your 'ought to' shit

2017-08-26 08:28:57 UTC  

That is really pushing it however, since apes in todays age are capable of using stick and stone tools.

2017-08-26 08:29:13 UTC  

And do apes have sentience?

2017-08-26 08:29:15 UTC  

It's arguable.

2017-08-26 08:29:18 UTC  

Evolution's a slow thing.

2017-08-26 08:29:22 UTC  

Very step by step.