Message from @Deleted User
Discord ID: 362845219319840769
not well atleast
even now one of the main purposes of government is to defend the people
Let me burst a bubble for you. What you have in your head about 'things' making people more powerful and being able to achieve things, are just imaginary power structures. What is really being done here but the re-arranging of duties in people's lives? This sacred thing you call 'government' is just made up of people pointed in a certain direction. We shouldn't limit ourselves to being controlled by this idea, but take it and realise it was the 'people' making this happen all along.
I understand the government is made by the people
it is made to defend and assist the people
Defence of what?
of the people inhabiting the land of the government
imagine
if there was an anarchist society
so
this means
no coherent military
no military funding or construction
now
if said society gets invaded
they are screwed
they cant produce enough to counter the enemy
actually
they could not produce at all
Anarchism is not a society or a system, it is just the negation of systems. People are free to achieve and cooperate much more than a petty government instruction.
but having that eliminates the possibility of a military
due to a military is a government upon itself
Military is just like government. The status quo in social relations.
yes
so a military is effectively impossible in an anarchy
In the traditional sense, of course.
is there a non traditional sense?
Raiders.
Offence vs defence remember?
yes
but raiders are unorganized
And I still want to ask you, defence of what? Private property.
no defence of lives
People are property of the ruling class.
and ability to support the people
Slavery.
yes
but this is authoritarianism
no upper class
So in a sense government is the reaction against raiders to defend property of labour.