Message from @olev

Discord ID: 384241844919468033


2017-11-26 07:11:44 UTC  

Socialism (in Marxism): a mode of production which has superseded capitalism and production is solely for use, the law of value is no longer present, production is coordinated through economic planning, and economic output is distributed based upon contribution

2017-11-26 07:13:35 UTC  

Communism: a state of society where all means of production are commonly owned and economic output is freely distributed, emerging from advancements in the productive forces which means there is material abundance

2017-11-26 07:14:45 UTC  

Marxism: economic/political theory of capitalism and class conflict

2017-11-26 07:14:57 UTC  

Also technically a philosophy

2017-11-26 07:16:20 UTC  

ok well the government has to be involved in order to keep this kind of society from collapsing on itself

2017-11-26 07:16:33 UTC  

do you agree that government involvement is necessary for this

2017-11-26 07:16:48 UTC  

How would it collapse

2017-11-26 07:17:42 UTC  

without government intervention people would not be coordinated

2017-11-26 07:17:57 UTC  

they would end up defaulting back to a capitalist system

2017-11-26 07:18:18 UTC  

capitalist systems are inevitable in societies with no government intervention

2017-11-26 07:18:24 UTC  

they just form

2017-11-26 07:18:28 UTC  

human nature

2017-11-26 07:18:36 UTC  

muh human nature

2017-11-26 07:18:44 UTC  

thats what it is

2017-11-26 07:18:48 UTC  

its not just some talking point

2017-11-26 07:19:03 UTC  

your vision of communism must have government intervention to work

2017-11-26 07:19:06 UTC  

Human nature isn't static, it changes based upon the structure of society

2017-11-26 07:19:10 UTC  

Both on a macro and micro scale

2017-11-26 07:19:32 UTC  

2000 years ago polygamy would be "human nature"

2017-11-26 07:19:42 UTC  

"your vision of communism"

2017-11-26 07:19:54 UTC  

You're constantly saying retarded shit and you're proving that you're uneducated

2017-11-26 07:20:22 UTC  

when i say "you're" I'm obviously talking about the entire ideology

2017-11-26 07:20:41 UTC  

There are no individual/unique visions of communism

2017-11-26 07:21:17 UTC  

human nature, if left alone and without government intervention, tends to default to the "survivalist" attitude, choosing what's best for the individual over the community

2017-11-26 07:21:27 UTC  

this can be seen all over the world

2017-11-26 07:21:27 UTC  

The difference lies with the means, not the ends

2017-11-26 07:21:46 UTC  

I just explained human nature

2017-11-26 07:21:57 UTC  

but do you have evidence to support it

2017-11-26 07:22:02 UTC  

have there been studies

2017-11-26 07:22:05 UTC  

There isn't a specific code of behavior in our DNA

2017-11-26 07:22:06 UTC  

whats the proof

2017-11-26 07:22:25 UTC  

What's the proof that greed is inherent and not influenced by the structure of society

2017-11-26 07:23:01 UTC  

there is behavior encoded into our dna from birth

2017-11-26 07:23:07 UTC  

such as survival instincts

2017-11-26 07:23:26 UTC  

Breathing, eating, and taking a shit

2017-11-26 07:23:31 UTC  

studies have shown that people tend to share personality traits with their parents

2017-11-26 07:23:39 UTC  

even if they are separated

2017-11-26 07:24:07 UTC  

Can you give me proof that humans are greedy from birth

2017-11-26 07:24:30 UTC  

That they are motivated by monetary incentive from birth

2017-11-26 07:24:46 UTC  

here's an example

2017-11-26 07:24:59 UTC  

if you were offered 1 cookie or 2 which would you take