Message from @quiscalus

Discord ID: 388494762782621696


2017-12-08 00:37:32 UTC  

I remember I used to play it all the time back in 2013 when I was a shitlet.

2017-12-08 00:38:25 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/388489462633463809/wvv561t6ceyy.jpg

2017-12-08 00:47:50 UTC  

howdy folks

2017-12-08 00:48:30 UTC  

what do you guys think is the best means to shift ownership of production to the workers in a nation like US?

2017-12-08 00:49:21 UTC  

also how does a business move from owners being shareholders or bosses to the workers in a non violent fashion?

2017-12-08 00:50:31 UTC  

@quiscalus Fuck off commie scum.

2017-12-08 00:51:30 UTC  

I assumed this place would be a good place to talk about leftist theory, why the hostility?

2017-12-08 00:52:17 UTC  

in USA only a very bloody revolution

2017-12-08 00:53:18 UTC  

This is a good place, but you have to watch out for the right-wing hanger-ons who troll these parts because the right can't meme.

2017-12-08 00:53:27 UTC  

well that happens

2017-12-08 00:53:45 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/388493320973975552/a63038745fed2e76452108a902f56aecf3a5e5928da1a7a4b15ad802c63ad3c8.png

2017-12-08 00:54:42 UTC  

I mean a revolution in USA will be the bloodiest shit ever

2017-12-08 00:54:46 UTC  

everyone has guns

2017-12-08 00:55:11 UTC  

@Deleted User you ever chat on stalingrad there is a pretty interesting friendly dude there from Russia that is a ML and supporter of the CPRF

2017-12-08 00:55:30 UTC  

invite me please

2017-12-08 00:55:58 UTC  

I had no idea that they get the 2nd most votes for president in the past 5 or 6 presidential elections

2017-12-08 00:57:33 UTC  

And to address your questions, the only solution is revolution. Unless of course your only goal is to democratize the workplace, in which case you can lean on economistic theories that will unfortunately not bring about actual socialism and can only result in petty-unionism which will effectively enable your movement to be absorbed by capitalism.

2017-12-08 00:57:50 UTC  

Resistance in the first world, Revolution in the third.

2017-12-08 00:58:11 UTC  

We need to stop capitalism from ever happening again.

2017-12-08 00:58:28 UTC  

@quiscalus Yes, I am on there from time to time. I know who you're talking about, seems like a cool dude.

2017-12-08 00:59:29 UTC  

I feel without nationalized industry production will be not coordinated in a fashion to best meet the needs of the people so it is important to have workers run the business but need information about how much to produce from centralized authority aka the state

2017-12-08 01:01:35 UTC  

@Deleted User also thanks for suggesting I read the state and revolution I am over half way done now at it really helps me understand Marx and his vision for revolutionary change, as a person who only read the communist manifesto I was not as familiar with that Marx outlined

2017-12-08 01:01:50 UTC  

I disagree, I think we should have some kind of SS to regulate the nation instead of the workers. Because the workers will only work in their own self interest but the SS (or whatever we called it) could work for the benefit of everyone.

2017-12-08 01:02:24 UTC  

It also shows how many people who claim to be socialists like a lot of social democrats are actually revisionists and subvert the goals of socialism

2017-12-08 01:02:54 UTC  

I agree, I believe that it is definitely important. I am, however, not a fan of cooperatives as they still have to compete in the market and often times the "worker-owners" end up bossing around other workers, as is the case with Mondragon, for example.

2017-12-08 01:03:19 UTC  

@quiscalus No problem, glad you're enjoying it.

2017-12-08 01:04:07 UTC  

yeah also the idea that coops are a means to revolutionary government is kind of absurd considering Mondragon operated under Franco and posed no threat to his government or him to their business

2017-12-08 01:04:14 UTC  

And yeah, the movement is rife with such types.

2017-12-08 01:05:06 UTC  

@quiscalus Exactly. I know quite a few anarchists and closeted social democrats who advocate such an organizational form. It's really absurd and very non-revolutionary.

2017-12-08 01:05:33 UTC  

I am a lot more sympathetic to the MLs and tankies especially learning more about how the revolution in October in 1817 came to be and the related push back my outside forces

2017-12-08 01:06:58 UTC  

I could be wrong but my theory is that since the huge anti soviet sentiment from the cold war makes people super reactionary and tend to not be interested in learning more about the ML prospective, at least that is what happened to me

2017-12-08 01:07:21 UTC  

Yeah, 16 foreign militaries, as well as the White Army, tried their best to stop the revolution in its tracks.

2017-12-08 01:07:50 UTC  

the 1817 revolution was funded by soros

2017-12-08 01:07:56 UTC  

Lol

2017-12-08 01:08:29 UTC  

@quiscalus Yeah, unfortunately the "Red Scare" and McCarthyism really left a negative impression.

2017-12-08 01:08:42 UTC  

yeah when you think about what Lincoln did in the civil war their reaction is not too unreasonable but you are practically considered stupid and unamerican if you are critical of Lincolns approach

2017-12-08 01:09:42 UTC  

My biggest criticism of the revolutionary left in the US it seems like it solely caters to very educated middle class folks and refuses to adapt to both explain and attract common working folks.

2017-12-08 01:09:54 UTC  

Yeah, I'm not too fond of Lincoln considering the fact that he was a closeted racist who would have gladly kept the institution of slavery in tact if it meant he could preserve the union while avoiding civil war.

2017-12-08 01:10:43 UTC  

using soviet imagery and Marxist jargon imo causes individuals to not even consider what is being said let alone open really having what is said change their opinion

2017-12-08 01:12:09 UTC  

I am just saying that other leaders remain blameless in the minds of most Americans but because our political prejudices we level hefty accusations against USSR without taking time to grasp the circumstances

2017-12-08 01:13:44 UTC  

@quiscalus Unfortunately there are a lot of academic types that are highly disconnected from the working-class movement, but there are also major organizations and groupings that are actively involved in their local communities doing things like feeding the homeless, setting up "free stores," combating gentrification, hosting book studies for people with little to no theoretical knowledge, and offering advanced, college-level classes at little to no cost.