Message from @Lucas 4313

Discord ID: 417178306530770964


2018-02-25 04:32:30 UTC  

you cannot just dissolve a state in this world

2018-02-25 04:32:36 UTC  

you will lose to outside forces

2018-02-25 04:32:40 UTC  

@Lucas 4313 Pol pot tried it.

2018-02-25 04:32:46 UTC  

pol pot failed

2018-02-25 04:32:59 UTC  

@Lucas 4313 He got taken out by his former comrades.

2018-02-25 04:33:20 UTC  

bakunin said "no it wouldn't dissolve itself" and not once has that happened in cases for socialism in which the state was conquered

2018-02-25 04:33:33 UTC  

rather than annihilated

2018-02-25 04:33:54 UTC  

@alines Indeed, marxist ideals really do not hold up.

2018-02-25 04:34:04 UTC  

Rex whos side are you on

2018-02-25 04:34:05 UTC  

what are you

2018-02-25 04:34:14 UTC  

@Lucas 4313 I'm a nazi.

2018-02-25 04:34:20 UTC  

oh right

2018-02-25 04:34:21 UTC  

he's anti-marxist, as a nazi

2018-02-25 04:34:22 UTC  

anyway

2018-02-25 04:35:04 UTC  

the state cannot dissolve unless the former state takes undeniable precedence over the world

2018-02-25 04:35:29 UTC  

@alines The issue with non marxist and anti marxist leftist beliefs, is that most of the time, they do not get far at all.

2018-02-25 04:35:50 UTC  

would it still? even in that case, when the state has conquered the whole world? i doubt it

2018-02-25 04:36:31 UTC  

we'll cross that bridge when we get there

2018-02-25 04:36:36 UTC  

we havent even come close

2018-02-25 04:37:17 UTC  

I mean, when you centralize the world, and everybody becomes dependant on a single state, there is no real reason to just say "OKAY, ANARCHY FOR ALL, FUCK STABILITY AND ALL THE PROGRESS WE HAVE MADE.".

2018-02-25 04:37:39 UTC  

thats....

2018-02-25 04:37:41 UTC  

not how it works

2018-02-25 04:37:45 UTC  

its not anarchy

2018-02-25 04:38:05 UTC  

i think the worst thing that could happen in a world-wide red bureaucracy is that it would deny its own existence

2018-02-25 04:38:28 UTC  

@Lucas 4313 Stateless society with no centralized form of power? That's anarchy in it's pure definition my man.

2018-02-25 04:38:36 UTC  

while still existing

2018-02-25 04:38:59 UTC  

@alines That's akin to trotsky's beliefs.

2018-02-25 04:39:18 UTC  

so if anarchy is the end goal, why jump through all these superviolent hoops?

2018-02-25 04:39:19 UTC  

the way I see it there is extremely small centralized government while the rest lives in what appears to be a state in perfect unison

2018-02-25 04:39:55 UTC  

@Lucas 4313 The way YOU see it? So much for being a marxist.

2018-02-25 04:40:04 UTC  

>small
>centralized
PICK ONE

2018-02-25 04:40:44 UTC  

you know theres local and central government, and they coexist literally everywhere

2018-02-25 04:40:56 UTC  

but the end goal is left to broad terms in most of marx's works

2018-02-25 04:40:58 UTC  
2018-02-25 04:41:17 UTC  

f e d e r a l

2018-02-25 04:41:45 UTC  

Yhea, the state is not exactly a local government, it is a regional government.

2018-02-25 04:42:19 UTC  

thats practically the same

2018-02-25 04:42:30 UTC  

No it isn't.

2018-02-25 04:42:39 UTC  

local = regional

2018-02-25 04:43:02 UTC  

and federation is more of an alliance/covenant between local bodies of government

2018-02-25 04:43:24 UTC  

local means city, or village