You must have issues pal.

falange did not defeat the anarchists simply by overwhelming them.
the anarchist disarmed by republican forces before falange got to them

Ah, avoiding now I see.

this has been my argument the entire time

@alines So instead of acknowledging your faults and responding to them, you simply ignore them and move onto something else? How pathetic you truly are.

repeating myself is moving on to something else.
yes calling people pathetic is always proof of your own validity. what's really pathetic is starting with saying i argue with myself, then saying i'm avoiding the topic i keep making the exact same comments on.
that's pathetic

Oh I am not doing this for myself, but I am calling you out on your short comings which you are extremely stubborn on and refuse to acknowledge, and then I called you out again for attempting to ignore them.

you'll just grab on to any fallacy you can think of instead of saying, "no the anarchists still had weapons, falange just overwhelmed them."
say it

make it clear, what are those shortcomings?

What? That is what I have been trying to say for the longest time, but yet you have gone on your nonsensical rants and what not, derailing this whole conversation.

One of your biggest shortcomings are your stubborness you will argue for the sake of arguing, and will refuse to ever admit that you are in the wrong. The second is your wording and text, seeing as how you can't make hardly any argument that holds up over time, and you constantly have to change, restate, and give up all together, just because you cannot string a proper sentence and statement together, without seeming like a person who cannot make up his mind to save his life.

i've been saying over and over that the republican government betrayed the revolution in barcelona and catalonia.
they did.
many times.
but i guess now they didn't because you said so.

insult after insult, and projection.
that is the crux of your thinking

and being betrayed by the republican government didn't lead to the defeat of the anarchists, is that what you're gonna say next?

@alines Did I ever claim that they didn't?

Projection? Insulting? Hah.

'pathetic' 'stubborn'
not insults, i suppose

They are harsh critisisms of what you really are.

how is 'pathetic' a criticism and not just plainly an insult?

@Queef Madagascar as for you,
anarchists made many attempts to educate the workers, many were successful, and published the philosophy that made the second republic of spain possible.
they increased literacy, made honest attempts at training workers for fighting, established worker's syndicates, collectivized labor and industry, and helped to bring down the monarchy and established democratic territories for themselves.
yup, we're just ALL empty promises

fuck you

anarchist and communist should always support each other

we might have different POVs

but like we all want the same

@alines Fuck you and your idealistic horseshit. You anarchists have contributed so little to the international socialist movement and have gotten in the way of socialist construction so many times as to make you an enemy of anyone that desires true freedom for working people.

@alines Because it is a critism about your behaviour.

Fuck anarchism.

Stupid, idealistic pipe-dream.

@Deleted User For once I agree with the internationalists.

Long Live Marxism!

Except the marxism part.

@alines The anarchists did not do shit, and all you blame it on is other people, you are a living example of this, with how you fail to acknowledge any of your failure, and instead screech at other people.

There was one anarchist society and that lasted for 3 years and there are only scraps of info

care to remember which society was that?

@Artemis Kulaks?

Catalonia

wow

It was barely ancom it was more of a refugee camp for war victims

With the civil war going on they had no choice but to ration resources to keep people alive

Of course a real ancom never existed so ancoms have the advantage of making unfalsifiable claims

Like Chomsky

@Queef Madagascar That's some real anarchism right there, a refugee camp that had to give up anarchism.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgteTrnKx5I