Message from @Onyxdood

Discord ID: 488547860489437185


2018-09-10 03:10:16 UTC  

The state holds the monopoly of power, so protects the peoples property rights and so on. When a state doesnt you have essentially mexico, with cartels running things

2018-09-10 03:10:22 UTC  

Either in shadows, or directly

2018-09-10 03:10:27 UTC  

The state is the exact opposite of the NAP

2018-09-10 03:10:58 UTC  

The state hardly does anything to protect your property, in a practical day-to-day sense. You do

2018-09-10 03:11:45 UTC  

Wrong, the state holds laws that protect your right to personal property

2018-09-10 03:11:58 UTC  

While also violating the same rights

2018-09-10 03:11:59 UTC  

If your home is broken into, the police investigate and so on.

2018-09-10 03:12:22 UTC  

If you say 'Taxes are a violation of property' grow up

2018-09-10 03:12:22 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki But in the end, it's not the laws that *prevent* damage or theft of your property. It's YOU and your actions.

2018-09-10 03:12:35 UTC  

Actually it is laws to prevent

2018-09-10 03:12:37 UTC  

Have you never heard of eminent domain?

2018-09-10 03:12:40 UTC  

As a deterrant

2018-09-10 03:13:17 UTC  

Eminent Domain requires a payment for such, of equal value

2018-09-10 03:13:28 UTC  

I would also appreciate if we don't attack each other with insults

2018-09-10 03:13:40 UTC  

@Onyxdood Ehh, that's debateable as to how well laws work as a deterrent. I'd say you and your firearm at home do more than the police ever do.

2018-09-10 03:13:41 UTC  

I have heard of eminent domain, and believe it should be more limited

2018-09-10 03:14:12 UTC  

^ Yes, and the powers of such is highly limited by the constitution and Legal President

2018-09-10 03:14:19 UTC  

Precident*

2018-09-10 03:14:32 UTC  

Also, a whole nother discussion lol

2018-09-10 03:14:36 UTC  

The same legal Powers have been slowly but surely expanding over the course of hundreds of years

2018-09-10 03:14:46 UTC  

As is the nature of the state

2018-09-10 03:15:28 UTC  

And the people keep the state in check, its all check and balances all the way down.

2018-09-10 03:15:44 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki But, to explore your question: How are local police paid with property taxes municipally, not an extension of the NAP?

2018-09-10 03:16:04 UTC  

I never said it wasn't.
I said NAP ONLY works with State enforcement

2018-09-10 03:16:17 UTC  

They'll always come a point where the state cannot be checked by people

2018-09-10 03:16:37 UTC  

Maybe in one without the express set up like the US

2018-09-10 03:17:10 UTC  

Then how do we ask the people keep something like the NSA in check?

2018-09-10 03:17:15 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki I might concede to a middle ground of: The NAP can only work if there's a monopoly on the law system

2018-09-10 03:17:16 UTC  

To many clauses and releifs to the people.

But again, I prefer that to say, Cartel rulership

2018-09-10 03:17:41 UTC  

@Onyxdood Whissle blowers

2018-09-10 03:17:43 UTC  

@Fitzydog And who holds the monopoly?

2018-09-10 03:18:06 UTC  

@zoopokemon and where is Edward Snowden at now?

2018-09-10 03:18:06 UTC  

Whissle Blowers into the Court systems. @Onyxdood

2018-09-10 03:18:07 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki idk, at that point you might as well call that monopoly a 'state' for all I care lol

2018-09-10 03:18:56 UTC  

You realize there are hundreds of other whistleblowers all the time. All don't end up like Snowden, who prolly did it as stupid as possible.

2018-09-10 03:19:04 UTC  

And then more or less defected.

2018-09-10 03:19:29 UTC  

And yet the NSA is still here

2018-09-10 03:22:29 UTC  

The NSA won't go anywhere, but they were driven back some on powers.

Again, Snowden didn't do it correctly. Correctly would have been going to a court with the same security clearances or congress. NSA falls under the Executive Branch. Judicial and Legislative are there to check the Executive. If you spill secrets like he did, there are laws about the handling of information.

2018-09-10 03:22:55 UTC  

Dude wasn't even smart enough to do it annonymously

2018-09-10 03:23:31 UTC  

My immediate question would be then why hasn't the Supreme Court ruled the NSA unconstitutional

2018-09-10 03:23:32 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki Yeah, I'd never trust the other intelligence agencies lol