Message from @Whithers
Discord ID: 778081722868170754
I find it all very fascinating. I rarely have much to contribute except encouragement to make me understand what people think.
Agreeing is an entirely separate matter.
I don't generally become a contrarian and debate people I agree with.
Also, YAY SLIDES!
I have the problem of having grown up in a family of librarians, teachers, and ministers. And not having taken a single American lit course until I got to college. I speak the same words as everyone else, it just isn't the same language.
Yis.
true but it is nice to see people getting involved..never would have seen this response a few year back
This is almost like 110-115 years ago. It was remarked how Americans would get off work, go home and change out of their work clothes into a suit, and hit the pub to debate politics.
I don't think I act as contrarian with people with whom I agree.
I do if they misrepresent something on the other side.
That's about it.
It's common they do that though.
Straw-manning hurts all causes.
Can you always tell a straw-man from a different perspective?
lol..the numbers will get larger here as this moves forward
Unless you acknowledge your straw man and its purpose. That's a thing.
That's usually called taking things to the extreme.
@Whithers yes, if it's your own position they are misrepresenting.
reason im here i like what your selling
In between black and white there are 10,000 shades of color, but they still fall to one side or the other.
Or if they are misrepresenting something that was agreed upon as someone else's position.
I like to understand the actual arguments of my opposition.
So I don't strawman them.
So I don't take their position for an extreme position.
I can sometimes point out their position can lead to extreme outcomes.
Straw man is a specific thing. It's not about your opinion of their opinion. It's deliberately misrepresenting what their opinion is so you can attack the misrepresentation.
Used to have a 1st Sgt that would say, clean is clean. If it isn't clean, it's dirty. Right is right, if it isn't right, it's wrong.
1st sgts love aphorisms. Brevity is the soul of wit.
What if their opinion isn't reality?
dont get caught up the whats being said to much...just be you and everthing works out
Aye.
The show today was somewhat contentious, as I think Rob took a more practical approach.
So both sides were a little upset.
that a good thing
Doesn't matter whether their opinion isn't reality. That's what you're arguing against.
@osok Yeah, I can't go with that. There are conditions which prevent "being you" from being a good thing.
or at least a tolerated one.
Lmao everyone got pissed.
Believe me, I know they did.
Better to notice a Straw man or play devils advocate then to accept ones argument as the complete truth with no substance to back it up.