yes

no

Only briefly

What’s a state?

No

no

So in other words, no

it has happened before and they still exist

Defend your position faggots

people form governments to counter a stateless society

Hoppe

communes are literally

stateless societies

No

How will a stateless society defend itself from a state?

it cant

voluntary army

Nice

stateless socites dont work large scale

All of those armies rebel

@Doctor Anon A volunteer army won't do well against a fully trained, professional army with tanks, aircraft, etc

Ideal communism ftw..

but small scale can work

look at the freikiorps

FREIKORPS

Yes

worked well for killing commies

then started a rebellion

Though i dont think it can scale to a large one

It could be *possible* though

Everyone loved the freikorps until the Kapp Putsch

that almost destroyed germany

@Doctor Anon Sure it is


Just ask Somalia.

Stateless society's past one person dont work

<:SquidDab:459545666725609493>

A stateless society is possible, I know of a few and they had to have existed at one point before civilization

But a stateless nation is by definition not possible

this is without even pondering whether it is ideal or effective by any means

Stateless nation isn't possible?
What is: Euskadi
What is: Punjab
What is: Uyghur people
What is: The Kurds
@EyeKanSpel

A nation is not the same thing as a nation-state. They're separate terms.

"na·tion

ˈnāSH(ə)n/

noun

a large aggregate of people united by common descent, history, culture, or language, inhabiting a particular country or territory."