Message from @Cody
Discord ID: 517008916241055754
why should we punish companies for the crimes of the individual?
do we punish the employer of a murder?
The company has committed a crime too
Firstly, illegal worker or not, the company employed someone for less than minimum wage
That in itself is a serious felony
I do not see how?
Your saying we shouldn't punish someone for hiring a person who can not legally work?
And if so, why?
You are using minimum wage to punish employers for an employees willingness to work for less than min wage
Then we punish them for hiring an illegal immigrant
then lets punish gab for having a murder on their platform
The problem will never go away until the company's themselves stop hiring illegals
they will never stop hiring so long as they are here.
So we must decentivize that
which incentives shipping jobs overseas anyway.
Then we need to secure our borders, then lower minimum wage
And outright abolish it slowly
Grenade, you do not see it as a crime to intentionally hire someone who can not legally work?
There was both intent, and action
we have ppl here supporting the minimum wage?
hasn't that been debunked to death aleady?
"Think about it, having no minimum wage would not incentivize hiring Americans"
Perhaps not directly, but if it costs a couple dollars less, it's less of a disincentive.
"An American still looks to progression in their wage
An illegal, would work for the same small amount forever if they could"
Completely incorrect. Illegals look to increase their wages like everyone else. They just recognize that it's going to be harder to do it above the table. But make no mistake, an illegal alien will eagerly look to make more money. And not all Americans necessarily look for raises, some want less working hours.
"It would just lead to actual Americans seeing wages fall, and it wouldn't solve the illegal workers problem"
This is correct. Though I think you're oversimplifying. Most Americans would be unaffected. This is why many minimum wage hikes appear to have negligible effect--the equilibrium price for labor already cleared the price floor.
"It was illegal immigrants working for less than minimum wage
We need to punish companies who hire illegal immigrants, and decentivize them in those feilds"
There's more to it than that. For example, you can still offshore labor. Do agree we shouldn't be encouraging companies to circumvent labor law by hiring illegal persons and they should be punished.
"But as it stands, lowering the minimum wage wont actually fix anything, and getting rid of it would just cause unnecessary civil unrest"
But raising it doesn't help either. As it stands, it might be inflating away with time, which can be the same effect without needing to go through the political process.
I'm not for the minimum wage
why should companies be allowed to hire illegal workers?
But hey, dont read what I wrote
Its fine
illegals workers can't be a problem if you punish companies that hire them
it's pretty simple actually
I was talking to belial
I was reading your things just now pratel
2 complaints, I never mentioned raising the minimum wage
"Grenade, you do not see it as a crime to intentionally hire someone who can not legally work?"
i do not have a problem with someone not invading someones personal life if they are willing to work, no.
@.B At the very least, it's a disincentive. It would cut down on economic migrants, but it wouldn't eliminate them. You'd still have people come over for welfare or unaware they'd struggle to find work.
And I want to decentivize companies hiring illegals
pot is illegal still, i don't report my neighbors to the police
So we punish them for doing so