Message from @The Ghost of Monarchies
Discord ID: 519420400443326474
chaotic is non deterministic isn't it?
If causality does not exist, then you can't vonsciously cause anything to happen, so what use would free will be?
No
Chaotic is deterministic, but so complicated to appear as non-deterministic
free will is choice
no
choice is not about knowing what will happen when you choose it
Non deterministic is what mises meant by chaotic above.
But you can predict
people make mistakes when they make choices
ffs
Quite easily
the point is they have the freedom to make mistakes, that is free will.
fate can be called circumstance
you are all born into circumstance
You can predict because at the very least a lot of causal(I believe all), but that doesn't mean free will needs everything to be causal
thus there is fate and free will
Here's what it boils down to
>Free will doesn't exist
Therefore your life under the presumption of free will doesn't matter because you are physically and mentally incapable of grasping what it means to be on a path you can't alter, there's no alternate step, your atoms vibrate as they have been ordained to.
>Free will does exist
Therefore your life under the presumption of free will existing or not doesn't matter because it's your choice to act the way you do, it was by your own free will to forfeit the responsibility to the intangible that is lack of free will
If every choice you make can only result in unitended consequences then you don't have free will.
It just means free will would be useless if nothing was causal
BUT EITHER WAY THIS DOESN'T PROVE WHETHER FREE WILL EXISTS OR NOT
@Timcast Criticizing Migration Will Be ILLEGAL In Europe?!?! Video missed out the part where the MEP states any news outlet that critiques migration will be shut down. So it's not just criminalising that type of speech, its shutting down the press
look
this is what my philosophy professor struggled with
you're conflating definitions to extremes
it's very simple
both co-exist
Cause and effect exists
But it's not binary, it's not X happens therefore Z down the line is inevitable
Hard to say
it
is not hard to sayu
none of this should be difficult to understand
Fate is not a thing
fate is circumstance you are born into
agree or no
yes or no
I'm not talking about fate. I'm talking about chaotic systems
Meaning birthplace
?
The uncertainty principle supports determinism, postivist NPCs.