@inky i literally just said I'd probably just define logical claims as logic

so , gravity exists, a logical claim is not philosophy

That's not a purely logical claim

You're making a claim about physical reality

Sorry about that, I did not read your text correctly

so is, a circle is square

Fran what shape is the earth

one is just true

Logical claims can be proved directly from premises. If I say "All X are Y" this implies logically "Not Y implies not X"

If I say all apples are red, if it's not red it's not an apple

were all globies

and its late

im of to bed

bye

this is logically true even if all apples aren't red, this is logically valid

It's not logically sound because there are some green apples

so what makes it philosophical

philisophy is the process of going through this argumentation

This logical deduction or inference or abduction

usually philsophical arguments are many premises long

so if there is no argument there is no philosophy?

i just have to say this: @Fran dude, not everything in life is philosophy, cmmon lol

ok bye

^

@inky any logical argument is inherently philosophical

it's either deductive abductive or inductive

so if there is no argument there is no philosophy?

I don't know, that's a weird claim

If there's no argument is there still knowledge?

Is there still truths?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic

logical arguments are LOGICAL, not philosophical WTF dude

Apples an be red green yellow and brown are you racist to apples or something @Fran

Logic can be described as pure common sense

@Alexxx does logic give you knowable statements?

what you claim is absurd and im done trying to understand your twisted form of philosophy

statements with information?

what you claim is not what the academic community considers philosophy

Exactly

you are using a waaaay to broad definition of philosophy dude... the love of knowledge definition