they are not lined up in the ecliptic

as i stated 10 times

<#538929818834698260>

Lol their ecliptic isnt lined up for an eclipse? You realize its called the ecliptic because that's how you have eclipses right?

Eclipse. Ecliptic plane. The plane eclipses happen on.

!mute @TheNidhugg

aw ok

i was liking the discussion

i asked many times to move to civil debate

he isnt intertested in answers or what we believe or do not believe

i think he gave an answer a few times to how it can work but you didnt accept them as accurate answers

Oh really?

I may have missed it

We were talking about refraction and infrared

He ignored that and sent a debunk video from a different observation

Never watched the video i sent

Then changed the subject to the moon

wasnt it about eclipses in the first place

He couldnt even think about what I was saying

This is flat earth chat not globe earth eclipse class

I asked a simple thing

ok

what were you saying

During some selenelion eclipses the darkening of the moon (shadow lets call it) starts from the top of the moon.

So you have the sun above one horizon and the moon above opposite horizon

But the shadow is on the top of the moon

The earth is below both sun and moon

Its very strange

He was welcome to preach to.his hearts content in the debate room but this room is not intended for a huge debate

yeah the description of the channel says that

I dont see why that is so much trouble

i dont know much about selenelion eclipses so ill take your word on it until i look into it more when im interested enough

is it something that supposed to support the flat earth or globe

It doesnt support the heliocentric model

Has nothing to do with flat earth really

More of indirect evidence

ok

i was looking at some sources when you and nin were talking

"The little-used name for this effect is called a "selenelion," a phenomenon that celestial geometry says cannot happen.

And indeed, during a lunar eclipse, the sun and moon are exactly 180 degrees apart in the sky. In a perfect alignment like this (called a "syzygy"), such an observation would seem impossible. But thanks to Earth's atmosphere, the images of both the sun and moon are apparently lifted above the horizon by atmospheric refraction. This allows people on Earth to see the sun for several extra minutes before it actually has risen and the moon for several extra minutes after it has actually set."

essentially it all boils down to atmospheric refraction based on what this says