I’d beg to differ with what he meant considering where later regimes went in regards to religious policy

(State atheism)

1. Marx never advocated for secularism. he advocated for the withering away of the state
2. thats literally the quote. "Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people". im not sure how you can interpret this in any other way to what i mentioned. He is saying that religion gives people hope which is why so many oppressed people (workers) were religious. Opium in those days was literally a painkiller. He is essentially saying that it makes people complacent with this life while giving them hope for the next

if you just take that quote to mean "haha drugs bad therefore religion bad" then im not sure what to do with you lol

Isn’t something that gives you false hope arguably a bad thing?

@Eno Can you tell me about what his new claim is

retarded claim*

@Ginnungagap

How can you read my mind?

I've been thinking that the entire time

its not as simple as that. you have a very simplistic view of it all. Marx is saying that its a product of the oppression the workers experience. he's not advocating for "state atheism" because "state atheism" will not, according to marx, be required once workers are liberated from this oppression @Flash

Marx was literally a Hegelian in his younger years lmao

According to Marxist theory there won’t be a state at all once workers are liberated

he's not saying religion bad or religion good, but rather religion is

"State Atheism"

ok retarrd

exactly @Flash

@Ginnungagap thats why i put it in quotation marks

cause its what he said

Then how could there be state atheism at that point

flash i mean

I know

Thats stupid

He was heavily inspired by Hegel

``Then how could there be state atheism at that point``

thats exactly what im saying lmao

The state atheism comes during the dictatorship of the proletariat

its why your claim that stalin's state atheism is somehow linked to marx is absurd

and not based in any understanding of marx

because marx was not a secularist

nor a theocrat

Wdym the only thing stalin did was ban the open religious practice iirc

I mean every socialist regime I can think of was to an extent state atheist so had to have come from somewhere

yes they have all been largely secular

(then criminalized homosexuality to appease the orthodox church)

this does not mean marx was a secularist

and that in turn does not mean marx supported some sort of state religion

Marx described religion as how he saw it and how he thought it came about

nothing more nothing less

iirc Marx said homosexuality was a biproduct of capitalism

not that im aware of lmao

i know the Castro's were extremely homophobic as well as Stalin