Message from @Leo (BillNyeLand)

Discord ID: 535173555986497548


2019-01-16 19:05:42 UTC  

But no one expects an *effective* tax rate of 70%

2019-01-16 19:06:14 UTC  

If they wanted an effective rate of 70%, they would set an effective rate of 70%. But they only want a *marginal* rate of 70%.

2019-01-16 19:06:39 UTC  

And government should live within its long-term means anyways, but that’s unrelated to the current or proposed tax rate.

2019-01-16 19:06:42 UTC  

They want an effective tax rate

2019-01-16 19:06:45 UTC  

thats the whole point

2019-01-16 19:06:49 UTC  

mostlikely would try to close loopholes

2019-01-16 19:06:53 UTC  

Which will result in a crash

2019-01-16 19:07:00 UTC  

They can close loopholes

2019-01-16 19:07:14 UTC  

yes and that increases the tax rate closer to 70%

2019-01-16 19:07:18 UTC  

Which is a crash

2019-01-16 19:07:22 UTC  

And AOC herself said she knew 70% marginal wasn’t 70% effective

2019-01-16 19:07:38 UTC  

And intended the former and not the latter

2019-01-16 19:07:50 UTC  

where

2019-01-16 19:07:56 UTC  

Nobody says "effective tax"

2019-01-16 19:08:00 UTC  

they want to tax the rich 70%

2019-01-16 19:08:13 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/441728840025374731/535173447853146132/image0.jpg

2019-01-16 19:08:13 UTC  

but herself and bernie do not understand marginal tax rates doesn't mean the tax is paid at that rate

2019-01-16 19:08:22 UTC  

Where does it say

2019-01-16 19:08:24 UTC  

effective

2019-01-16 19:08:31 UTC  

“That doesn’t mean all $10M are taxed at an extremely high rate”

2019-01-16 19:08:38 UTC  

Only the money after the first $10M

2019-01-16 19:08:49 UTC  

the phrase after is important

2019-01-16 19:08:54 UTC  

Yes

2019-01-16 19:08:55 UTC  

she makes no distinction between effective or not

2019-01-16 19:09:07 UTC  

She shows she understands the different though

2019-01-16 19:09:18 UTC  

*difference

2019-01-16 19:09:43 UTC  

Not all the $10M is taxed at 70%. That was never the plan, and AOC understand that

2019-01-16 19:09:43 UTC  

She doesn't

2019-01-16 19:09:48 UTC  

she just says a progressive tax rate

2019-01-16 19:10:02 UTC  

after 10 million

2019-01-16 19:10:08 UTC  

Which doesn't distinct effective tax rate

2019-01-16 19:10:20 UTC  

because the highest tax rate was 45% effectively

2019-01-16 19:10:24 UTC  

there was no "progression"

2019-01-16 19:10:30 UTC  

I highlighted it for you

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/441728840025374731/535174022590234634/image0.png

2019-01-16 19:11:03 UTC  

Yeah she outlines a progressive system after that

2019-01-16 19:11:04 UTC  

Not all $10M is taxed at 70%, which is what separates a marginal rate from an effective rate

2019-01-16 19:11:07 UTC  

Yes

2019-01-16 19:11:07 UTC  

which is not the case

2019-01-16 19:11:12 UTC  

A progressive marginal rate

2019-01-16 19:11:14 UTC  

because there is no progression

2019-01-16 19:11:17 UTC  

There is