Message from @Spookaswa

Discord ID: 524078472889499648


2018-12-17 04:18:45 UTC  

Like in the Napoleonic wars

2018-12-17 04:18:47 UTC  

the war was lost in 1941

2018-12-17 04:18:50 UTC  

But he refused to abandon it

2018-12-17 04:18:59 UTC  

and further, they DIDN'T HAVE THE BLOODY OIL

2018-12-17 04:19:01 UTC  

none of it

2018-12-17 04:19:03 UTC  

it was running out

2018-12-17 04:19:07 UTC  

wehrmacht dead in the water

2018-12-17 04:19:20 UTC  

And if they captured Moscow, all the rail ways in ALL of Russia would have been cut off

2018-12-17 04:19:26 UTC  

Muh central planning lmao

2018-12-17 04:19:29 UTC  

They would need to get as far as the Urals in order for the USSR to be neutralized

2018-12-17 04:19:46 UTC  

Further, we know that during the Battle of Moscow, the Wehrmacht was halted. As in, it suffered casualties probably in the hundreds of thousands - we'll probably never know how much exactly - and the *thrust was halted.*

2018-12-17 04:19:55 UTC  

You think that the USSR would just bend over because muh railways?

2018-12-17 04:19:56 UTC  

kek

2018-12-17 04:20:00 UTC  

Reaching Moscow failed not only in theory, but on the battlefield as well.

2018-12-17 04:20:02 UTC  

@Xinyue IN NOVEMBER

2018-12-17 04:20:11 UTC  

When the tanks froze on the fields

2018-12-17 04:20:21 UTC  

Leaf. Literally millions of Red Army troops in reserve to the East of Moscow.

2018-12-17 04:20:26 UTC  

The Wehrmacht lost its offensive capabilities in 1942

2018-12-17 04:20:34 UTC  

If they reached Moscow in October The Red army was fucked

2018-12-17 04:20:43 UTC  

No transport by rail

2018-12-17 04:20:44 UTC  

No, it would only have been a setback

2018-12-17 04:20:50 UTC  

I get that for the nazis its hard to admit, but the Soviet Union was confident enough on the Eastern Front to keep six million troops in reserve

2018-12-17 04:21:13 UTC  

Stalin would be ready to put every soviet citizen in between him and Germany

2018-12-17 04:21:38 UTC  

@Spookaswa he literally stayed in Moscow when the Nazis were 20km from the Kremlin

2018-12-17 04:21:56 UTC  

The entire battle between Moscow was basically just throwing men at Germany attempting to slow them down until they thought of an actual plan lmao

2018-12-17 04:22:06 UTC  

Even if they somehow captured him, significant resistance would still be highly likely

2018-12-17 04:22:33 UTC  

Also, the CPSU =/= Stalin

There were literally people down the line ready to take full command. His most entrusted, his most cherished commanders, many public figures, party members who had gained his favour, etc. etc. Unlike Nazi Germany which was Hitler's personal project, USSR wasn't Stalin's. It wasn't tied to Stalin, it was tied to *Lenin's legacy.* USSR transcended Stalin in a way that Nazi Germany **never transcended Hitler**

2018-12-17 04:22:36 UTC  

Stalin would probably kill him self

2018-12-17 04:23:07 UTC  

@Spookaswa Stalin was he lynchpin, without him the leadership would disintegrate because he had terrorized everyone for so long

2018-12-17 04:23:43 UTC  

In fact much of the war showed how the Red Army fought well without Stalin's interference

2018-12-17 04:24:09 UTC  

2018-12-17 04:24:19 UTC  

this is a complete non-point not only because of USSR would've kept going even if they got to Stalin, but also because Stalin wouldn't ever have stayed in Moscow to face certain death

2018-12-17 04:24:35 UTC  

Moscow isn't to USSR in 1941 what Berlin is to Germany in 1945

2018-12-17 04:25:11 UTC  

Moscow would have been Stalingrad in 1941, at the center of the soviet supply grid, with no Volga to block soviet reinforcements

2018-12-17 04:25:21 UTC  

It would have been a slaughterhouse for germans

2018-12-17 04:25:38 UTC  

> Stalin was he lynchpin, without him the leadership would disintegrate because he had terrorized everyone for so long

except no, not at all true. If this was true, USSR would've collapsed in 1954. You demonstrate insufficient knowledge in the Soviet political life if you think this was the case.

2018-12-17 04:26:13 UTC  

Yeah Germans were always going to lose the war

2018-12-17 04:26:30 UTC  

if for no other reason, then for the depth of defense in USSR and the resource/oil angle

2018-12-17 04:26:43 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/507035890640486411/524079978086662163/image0.jpg

2018-12-17 04:26:49 UTC  

@Xinyue Russia wasn't at war in 1954 you dumb knee grow

2018-12-17 04:27:10 UTC  

It hadn't just gone through the purges