Message from @RoflTank

Discord ID: 518659847114457089


2018-12-02 05:24:59 UTC  

that is supposed to stop it

2018-12-02 05:25:09 UTC  

would that not make a juicy case for a slam dunk lawsuit?

2018-12-02 05:25:10 UTC  

shush now little one

2018-12-02 05:25:18 UTC  

NIJ standards are here

2018-12-02 05:25:23 UTC  

Let us peep

2018-12-02 05:25:30 UTC  

that being said, how exactly is it that these companies stay in business?

2018-12-02 05:25:42 UTC  

unless their armor actually stops the rated threat

2018-12-02 05:26:23 UTC  

.17HMR 17gr doing 2600 fps out of a rifle

2018-12-02 05:26:31 UTC  

goes through IIIA

2018-12-02 05:26:40 UTC  

discussion is related to .22lr not .17hmr

2018-12-02 05:26:45 UTC  

much faster than .22lr or 5.7x28

2018-12-02 05:27:35 UTC  

I have a whole new respect for .17HMR

2018-12-02 05:27:38 UTC  

Not gonna lie

2018-12-02 05:27:44 UTC  

However, back to the argument

2018-12-02 05:28:00 UTC  

II and IIA is designed to stop 9mm and .40 round nose

2018-12-02 05:28:06 UTC  

FMJ

2018-12-02 05:28:09 UTC  

No AP

2018-12-02 05:28:30 UTC  

Based on the test criteria, the armor needs to have limited BFD

2018-12-02 05:28:49 UTC  

Which means it's not meant for penetrative ballistics, it's basically a kevlar shock pad.

2018-12-02 05:29:03 UTC  

A small, fast round will penetrate textile armor readily

2018-12-02 05:29:32 UTC  

but .22lr isn't .17HMR fast

2018-12-02 05:29:43 UTC  

In fact, based on the 2-4-16-64g test criteria for fragmentation resistance, armor rated for actual AP threats is *weaker* against 2-4g threats.

2018-12-02 05:29:56 UTC  

even .22 mag isn't fast enough

2018-12-02 05:30:10 UTC  

Which requires its own type and technique of textile weaving to defeat

2018-12-02 05:30:43 UTC  

something something thread strength against targets they can't squeeze

2018-12-02 05:31:12 UTC  

what vest

2018-12-02 05:31:13 UTC  

what age

2018-12-02 05:31:16 UTC  

what humidity

2018-12-02 05:31:19 UTC  

what angle

2018-12-02 05:31:21 UTC  

what load

2018-12-02 05:31:24 UTC  

what location

2018-12-02 05:31:36 UTC  

what condition

2018-12-02 05:31:39 UTC  

how many rounds

2018-12-02 05:31:54 UTC  

There's a reason NIJ tests are done the way they are.

2018-12-02 05:32:03 UTC  

All of those factors affect textile armor

2018-12-02 05:32:13 UTC  

I have yet to find any compelling evidence showing that .22LR can defeat 3a

2018-12-02 05:32:25 UTC  

Which is why they're generally used alongside or as reinforcement to solid armor like cermaics or metals

2018-12-02 05:32:40 UTC  

the reason why it is probably not addressed is because they can't define an all-encompassing criteria for what .22LR it should defeat

2018-12-02 05:32:47 UTC  

Exactly.