Message from @MountainMan

Discord ID: 529431007712116737


2018-12-31 22:42:35 UTC  

@Goblin_Slayer_Floki You don’t need to remove them. Only need to make them stop fighting.

2018-12-31 22:43:17 UTC  

The Hadiths are NOT clear, which is the problem in many cases @Goblin_Slayer_Floki

2018-12-31 22:43:47 UTC  

Hadiths are not word of god, and should be listened to as if you read a normal book.

2018-12-31 22:44:07 UTC  

There are two types. Ones Mohammed said, and ones Allah said via Mohammed. But there is no label on the Hadith to say which it is.

2018-12-31 22:44:15 UTC  

^

2018-12-31 22:44:16 UTC  

They are also contradictory.

2018-12-31 22:44:20 UTC  

Yes

2018-12-31 22:44:34 UTC  

Some who even contradict the Quran itself.

2018-12-31 22:45:06 UTC  

the only solution is to kill them all

2018-12-31 22:45:49 UTC  

Is there really no possibility of forging a compelling third way between the two major sects?

2018-12-31 22:45:52 UTC  

Killing off a religion made to survive even through prosecution? Good luck.

2018-12-31 22:46:02 UTC  

prosecution?

2018-12-31 22:46:16 UTC  

@Legiondude There is. We shake hands and have normal civil debates.

2018-12-31 22:46:20 UTC  

Remember, most of the evidence that he was a prophet, were his own words proclaiming that God is speaking through him. So you have a problem, as apparently, God did not ALWAYS speak through him, but did not clarify when that is.

2018-12-31 22:46:27 UTC  

can a religion be sued?

2018-12-31 22:46:41 UTC  

@nutsnax Prosecution. People killing them.

2018-12-31 22:46:54 UTC  

oh, persecution got it

2018-12-31 22:47:11 UTC  

Ahh yes. I spelled it wrong.

2018-12-31 22:49:08 UTC  

everything I've read and heard about islam is scary

2018-12-31 22:49:21 UTC  

convert or die is the message i got

2018-12-31 22:49:48 UTC  

Which is pretty funny because force convertion dosent work.

2018-12-31 22:50:05 UTC  

i guess the die part would be employed then

2018-12-31 22:51:13 UTC  

Yes. Which wouldnt be allowed. There is one chapter (don’t remember the exakt one) which says that you aren’t allowed to kill unbelievers of you aren’t at War, and that you need to defend them if they ask for shelfen.

2018-12-31 22:51:32 UTC  

Muslims should Never forget that Muhammeds life was saved by the christian ethiopians.

2018-12-31 22:51:36 UTC  

is that in the Meccan or Medinan version?

2018-12-31 22:51:45 UTC  

Excuse me?

2018-12-31 22:51:51 UTC  

I don’t understand

2018-12-31 22:51:52 UTC  

I thought there were two versions

2018-12-31 22:51:58 UTC  

There is one Quran.

2018-12-31 22:52:05 UTC  

sorry, book I mean

2018-12-31 22:52:24 UTC  

when muhammed was in mecca then went to Medina

2018-12-31 22:52:29 UTC  

Oh. The Quran is the Only true one, the words by God.

2018-12-31 22:53:15 UTC  

He was not in Medina when the Ethiopians saved his followers, he was in Mecca

2018-12-31 22:55:06 UTC  

And seriously they basically turned up to Medina and "asked kindly to live there" and, unsurprisinlgly, althoufh the Jewish Medinans agreed they also hated them for getting them into wars.

2018-12-31 22:57:21 UTC  

@nutsnax About conversion, there is this Very interesting chapter which everyone always point to. Chapter 2. It says to kill the infidels wherever you find them, But immediatly tells you NOT to do that.

2018-12-31 22:58:25 UTC  

lol

2018-12-31 22:58:33 UTC  

Flip a coin.

2018-12-31 23:04:16 UTC  

So how did the thing with mittens go?

2018-12-31 23:04:30 UTC  

i think mitts gave up

2018-12-31 23:17:18 UTC  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HG-UbXPlG6Q

2019 is going to be a loooooooooong year

2018-12-31 23:19:21 UTC  

i can't wait for the inevitable military coup that will happen when people try to impeach bolsonaro when he turns out to be just as bad as his opposition