Message from @SteelandSouls

Discord ID: 514578806137159681


2018-11-20 23:01:59 UTC  

Pretty much the same.

2018-11-20 23:02:52 UTC  

To clarify I'm talking about "a supernatural being created the universe and then fucked off" vs "this virtue is God"

2018-11-20 23:03:13 UTC  

Which aren't the same

2018-11-20 23:03:58 UTC  

Theism is just religion

2018-11-20 23:05:11 UTC  

Or at least what people typically mean when they say religion

2018-11-20 23:05:28 UTC  

Sure

2018-11-20 23:06:13 UTC  

Monotheism is theism based around a God, like the Abrahamic faiths, Atheism is based around no Gods, either due to assertion of proof against or just lack of proof for

2018-11-20 23:06:20 UTC  

Theism is the common root

2018-11-20 23:06:24 UTC  

Still functionally the same. Jordan Peterson can’t state what he actually believes about God in his position.

2018-11-20 23:06:39 UTC  

Why do you figure that?

2018-11-20 23:07:18 UTC  

He has at one point saying that he does not but he lives like he does

2018-11-20 23:07:44 UTC  

Because the ideas are like denominations of the same religion.

2018-11-20 23:08:14 UTC  

Peterson gets called a Nazi and lectures on the bible all the time. I don't think saying "I'm Christian and believe in God" would hurt him

2018-11-20 23:08:39 UTC  

By that logic all Monotheism is just Zoroastrianism

2018-11-20 23:09:59 UTC  

The Christian God has specific properties. If you don't believe those properties how are you still a Christian?

2018-11-20 23:10:10 UTC  

Ok. I see your point.

2018-11-20 23:11:05 UTC  

But they are still functionally the same.

2018-11-20 23:11:45 UTC  

In some scenarios, sure. Does Peterson believe the creation story though? Or just use it as metaphor?

2018-11-20 23:12:05 UTC  

He treats it metaphorically

2018-11-20 23:12:17 UTC  

Does he believe the events in the Bible or see them as fables that he uses to create his own moral compass, hence his use of Nietzsche?

2018-11-20 23:12:27 UTC  

A blend of both

2018-11-20 23:12:50 UTC  

There are historical aspects of the bible and there are the miraculous/mystical aspects of it

2018-11-20 23:13:14 UTC  

Why is a deist required to view the creation of the universe through a Christian Lens ? Deism is the idea that God exist creative universe and stepped aside. That’s it.

2018-11-20 23:13:33 UTC  

^

2018-11-20 23:13:52 UTC  

Well that's the thing, has Peterson commented on creation? I only ever hear him talk about God as Order

2018-11-20 23:14:16 UTC  

He leans toward the evolutionary aspect of things.

2018-11-20 23:16:06 UTC  

That is called intelligent design.

2018-11-20 23:16:41 UTC  

The driving force in *evolution* isn't a designer though

2018-11-20 23:17:04 UTC  

Why isn't it though?

2018-11-20 23:17:55 UTC  

Because it's caused by environmental and genetic factors. It's measurable. Humans also went through it

2018-11-20 23:18:09 UTC  

Right...but the intelligent design would be its origin

2018-11-20 23:18:14 UTC  

Is the argument then that humans don't have free will, since everything about them was forced to be the way it is?

2018-11-20 23:18:22 UTC  

Right but we're talking about the process

2018-11-20 23:18:25 UTC  

Not the origin point

2018-11-20 23:18:44 UTC  

Right. But Intelligent Design would be the origin and evolution would be the process

2018-11-20 23:18:46 UTC  

Just because it’s measurable doesn’t mean that God isn’t n behind it.

2018-11-20 23:18:47 UTC  

The driving force in evolution is what makes it occur over time

2018-11-20 23:19:15 UTC  

@Salacious Swanky Cat then Free Will is a myth, because our progress and procreation are divinely controlled

2018-11-20 23:19:44 UTC  

This sounds like it's going into the free will vs predestination argument

2018-11-20 23:20:09 UTC  

@Beemann lol. Not entirely Mr. Calvinist.

2018-11-20 23:20:24 UTC  

Didn't the Christians have that argument a long time ago and the free will people won?