That's fine if he wants to but why would he want too?

For trade?

Thats fine

Also

but once it becomes controlling it has to be anaylzed, ctiqued, and if need be fixed

Other farmers would want to buy his surplus

If the rest of the people don’t, they will

Someone will buy it

If he makes enough of it

Or

If the quality is better

Thats true, and then they can participate in a gift economy

But it will really only be trading surpluses

However if the farmers buy the food they will be sacrificing something of their own so that they can give that food to the rest of the commune

Would at least some of them not want to be paid for it

They don't have to give anything to the commune

Its all voluntary

For support of the commune

Well yeah but I’m just saying that a market system forming is inevitable

Markets are fine, capitalism is not

But honestly it really isn't inevitable

And Markets themselves can be regulated or even abolished depending on a commune vote

How could they be abolished

If they were abolished, people would stop providing goods

Not really, they would just provide to the commune or keep for themselves

Collectivized job sites also kind of form their own commune

But that would mean a crucial main source of a good for the commune is now gone

Why would they do that

Why would who do what?

Eliminate markets

And other people who are a part of the commune would pick it up

and eliminating markets is just meaning the gift economy

though it would probably follow from the abolition of currency

Why would they pick it up though

This particular farmer or farmers were the best in their firld

Cause they don't want to starve?

Field

They made the highest quality food and knew how to farm

Eventually the cycle will happen again

Another farmer will be the best

And they will get frustrated