Message from @svarozhyc
Discord ID: 599154183878213642
linguistic ability
can you specify
so for example, I don't remember exactly since it was 10 years ago but 2 tasks are a vocabulary test, and another is spatial reasoning. I'll explain
they'll ask you to explain the definition of increasingly uncommon words
ok
starts with like dog and cat or whatever, goes up to "unstoppable" or "ubiquitous", and on and on
tell me, if you're a farmer who's never seen a school, how would you learn these increasingly uncommon words?
you have no incentive, and no way of learning it
spatial reasoning is rearranging blocks to fit a given pattern
yeah vocabulary is a poor measure of any sort of "general" intelligence imo
ye when even the racist says that
u know you're wrong
but then they change the rules unexpectedly and you have to kind of break the mould of your thinking, for example say you had 5 tasks to rearrange blocks with an explicit border around the outside then the 6th removed the border. it's an unfamiliar task and smarter people perform better at it
of course it is, 'general intelligence' helps find and retain vocab though
yeah, but if u never got the ability to learn this vocab
you're gonna be at a disadvantage because of economic reasons
sure
not because of genetic reasons
and for whatever reason, rearranging blocks is a really really good proxy for all sorts of things including mathematical ability
you never answered my question Vindi
yeah
it represents your ability to manipulate information with your mind
you can't train people to do this shit
im talking about the linguistic example
also yes you absolutely can
you can't take someone with downs syndrome and coach them to get a 160 on an IQ test
and it's not only vocab
yeah but you can train a normal person and help them get a higher IQ on the test
it's other things like verbal reasoning
so the thing is
as i said before
like you'll have to pick a word most similar
you cant do it with downies, but that's an extreme example
should rebrand IQ to something else
lol
most people don't have an etra chromosome
that requires genuine understanding now rote memorisation
and other th ings like pick the odd one out
because it is measuring something with some impact on person's life
you can train memorization