it really doesn't matter if the soul exists or not because the original discussion was about a hypothetical scenario in which the soul exists. this is not the time or place for fedora-tipping

You don't even know what trolling is dude

so, apparently the midget bagel guy has decided to get some mma training <:FeelTheBarn:591276979844808734>
https://twitter.com/FiteTV/status/1171545015715319810

@Imaorange disingenuous argument to get a rise out of someone

If it got a rise out of you then I was right

And you really would ask that

@Zeeviel disagreeing about dumb comments isn't fedora tipping.

Like a fucking brainlet retard who doesn't even have an operating idea of God

@Imaorange you didn't, I just thought you were serious ;)

@Imaorange you're pretty boring tbh

we were having a discussion about "if the soul exists, would bla bla bla" and you come in going "BUT IT DOESNT EXIST REEEEE"

It's so easy to avoid having to discuss difficult subjects if you just cast everyone tlaking to you as a troll

it really doesn't matter if it does or not

it's a hypothetical scenario

you're a brainlet little retard and are quite happy to be there

*petpetpet*

Anyway Zeev, we were having a discussion

i dont care to argue about whether religion is true or not, nobody is talking about that right now. *you* are trying to make it about that

Befre some horse-fag sweat mtn dew all over us

@Zeeviel ok, well nothing about your hypothetical follows unless you make some explicit assumptions about the soul

yes that's what hypothetical fucking means lmao

i'm starting to think *you're* the troll

@Zeeviel I'm not trying ti make it about that, it doesn't follow because they don't exist, but even within your hypothetical it doesn't follow

you just barge into the chat to tell everyone they're wrong

I know nothing about a soul

@Zeeviel so im engaging now and you're still mad

not mad, annoyed

Would you like to stop complaining and respond?

I think that having the idea that the soul is eternal that may imply some level of unified experience that would allow it to in some sense 'know' its past, present, and future states, but being able to tap into that knowledge is the unkown

explain how it doesn't follow

@Zeeviel idgaf about your feelings

Perhaps a limitation of our senses

@Zeeviel I already told you, I don't know anything about a soul. It relies on certain assumptions. Can souls experience things? Can they do it absent a body? Are they conscious? DO they come from heaven?

eternal may just mean 'everlasting' not 'beyond time' though. but given that in most faiths the soul is supposed to originate from a place beyond time, i would assume so yes

Perhaps it manifests in exterior stimulation or through momentary sensations that wouldn't strike one as the soul trying to connect memories or experiences together in the present

like random thoughts or inpulses

ur soul is located external at the source of ur feed

inspiration is music or art

perhaps it's the pineal gland!

Who knows

a soul is typically defined as some form of eternal supernatural consciousness with divine origins which inhabit an earthly vessel. so yes i would assume they can experience and know things