Message from @ubermensch
Discord ID: 634463755194990611
Again, that's exactly what Marx argued
Or by corporations?
I think that it's a natural evolution of technology that is irresistible (just as industrialization was)
I think most people can recognize and understand that there is a layer of predatory capitalism in the world
And that corporations see the writing on the wall and want to get ahead of it
If you leave it to its devices
You can absolutely maintain a healthy version of capitalism if you force its hand, but currently all signs indicate oligarchy. You don't counter with Marxism, not sure why you think I am, that's childish.
Sure, that's why a healthy capitalistic system requires checks and balances to prevent corporate takeover and consumer/worker abuse
@Redxl That may be so. But my point is that neither UBI nor increased minimum wage will ever solve that particular issue. Introduce UBI and the capitalists will just raise the prices to "fit" the UBI, leaving the average consumer with pretty much the same purchasing power as before (salaries will also probably be adjusted accordingly). Raise the minimum wage, and they'll do the same thing.
And i'm not just talking about the companies selling DVD's, this will happen with ALL of them.
I'm not saying you're a marxist kek, try to read better my friend
And there really isn’t a check to automation it’s just assumed it’s innately a good thing
I said you're making the same fundamental argument that Marx did on the evils of industrialization and why we needed to switch to communism before the industrial machines made everyone inextricably poor
i don't think rises in price necessarily correspond 1:1 to minimum wage increases
That the trucker who lost his job will be the drone pilot next or something
automation itself isn't good or bad, it's just a force, a tool
Both UBI and increases to minimum wage are basically just political red herrings. It's a talking point for ambitious politicians who want to make it seem like they're gonna make things better "for the little guy", but in the end all it does is maintaining the status quo for the little guy and his purchasing power.
anyone got a spare hell let loose key by any chance?
@Seven Proxies lol, that's exactly what I argued, "UBI will merely increase the baseline"
a nigga trying to get em games
go away beggar
Yall Rock just so you know
We control the machines not the other way around
@TheBadfish ill suck your cock faggot
nothin gay about gettin your dick sucked my man, only gay to suck a dick
@Death in June Not 1:1, but it is definitely a variable in the equation. other factors do influence pricing of course (logistical issues, capital etc.)
If you think we can resist the onset of automation forcibly, you don't understand industry and economy
Again though- you guys don't seem to realize the trends already indicate corporate servitude and an oligarchy in control of your politics. Mass automation, in this environment, is absolutely unsustainable. We'll be eating the wealthy alive in the streets by that point.
Overall we’re not talking about automation to allow X worker to do a job better. We’re talking about automation to make the worker innately removed from the equitation. Outside a couple technical hands.
Automating things that can be automated is simply a superior solution, no matter how you feel about it. It's our responsiblity to attempt to wield that power for the benefit of the masses and not to let the abusive corporations lead the way.
In any case, i'm not here to persuade you about it. I'm just saying, if you are a proponent of UBI or minimum wage, then you have to keep these factors in mind. How income baselines actually help the capitalist class reduce the purchasing power of the average consumer, while politicians think (or at least tries to make you think) that it will increase the purchasing power of the average consumer.
Yes, and that is literally the exact same argument used by anti-industrialists in the 1890s
And we’re they innately wrong?
i'm not sure that minimum wage generally serves to reduce the purchasing power of the average consumer
Yes
horses versus EVERYTHING ain't an argument.
Yes
I agree
You seem to have some bit hindsight 20/20 at play here.
No
if it has any utility to the capitalist class it would be 1. it can help to price out new competitors of the market and 2. it's an easy political ploy to get elected