But how does it exist without the state

a Dictator

Who redistributes

@gronkt Marx worked plenty, intellectual labour is very difficult

we have seen how it goes down many times already

and he got paid peanuts for it, his legacy is huge and writings are pure genius

Who redistributes? -.-

it is idealistic and can never work

the power of the people is all

Ok

I see

people are greedy selfish lazy animals

they are corruptable

happens every time

one can say that america in its early phases was one of the most successful communes since everything was decided by councils

that was before big government and the civil war

They do work until they get attacked...

lol

America was ancap

no it wasnt ancap because capitalist was in its early phases

Built on self starters

there is nothin wrong with self starters, but having an advantage like the americans or australians where your given land is not really ancap, that is communism

If you're sharing stuff with your family it's not communism

Which was all America back then

yes but if you also share with community it is

bartering local trade

Most communities back then were related to each other

decentralised everything is communism

so it is possible for a nation but not for the whole planet

then it becomes the NWO

i think federalisation within nations and maintain trade on a planetary scale idealistic but possible

It's possible

yes i agree i hate th idea of any nwo world governemnt

But retarded

hahah perhaps time will tell

Why would you want the world's economies tied together?

trade is necessary for a good life

why should one Country that worked it arse of mining resources just share them with another Country that has nothing and did no work to better themselves ?

plus all knowledge and technical advancement relies on sharing, localism is anathema to knowledge growth

Hmm

youre talking about a national spirit, as though the collective owns anything