Message from @Horse Shmeat

Discord ID: 337012315914502164


2017-07-18 23:23:52 UTC  

on the difference

2017-07-18 23:23:55 UTC  

Learn or choose negligence.

2017-07-18 23:24:02 UTC  

look up public vs private property

2017-07-18 23:24:04 UTC  

it's easy

2017-07-18 23:24:22 UTC  

private property does not exist

2017-07-18 23:24:28 UTC  

You're thinking of way too many abstractions for such a simple concept

2017-07-18 23:24:32 UTC  

Public property is property that is dedicated to public use and is a subset of state property. The term may be used either to describe the use to which the property is put, or to describe the character of its ownership (owned collectively by the population of a state).

2017-07-18 23:24:44 UTC  

If anything what you're really thinking of are private trade goods

2017-07-18 23:24:47 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/337011852183732224/Screenshot_143.png

2017-07-18 23:25:03 UTC  

Private property has a different definiton than the world definition

2017-07-18 23:25:03 UTC  

AKA private property you trade

2017-07-18 23:25:03 UTC  

So private property does exist?

2017-07-18 23:25:25 UTC  

different things have different definitions in different contexts

2017-07-18 23:25:48 UTC  

No you're using a connotative meaning for private property

2017-07-18 23:25:58 UTC  

because we are talking politics

2017-07-18 23:26:13 UTC  

not room privacy

2017-07-18 23:26:18 UTC  

@Horse Shmeat So the tooth brush that you used for yourself and only yourself is by definition private property?

2017-07-18 23:26:27 UTC  

No, it's personal property

2017-07-18 23:26:31 UTC  

do you rent out your brush?

2017-07-18 23:26:34 UTC  

Private means the same no matter what

2017-07-18 23:26:37 UTC  

do you make money with it?

2017-07-18 23:26:38 UTC  

no

2017-07-18 23:26:42 UTC  

it's personal property

2017-07-18 23:27:21 UTC  

Anyway so trade goods are banned but personal property isn't
Shit what did I want to ask way back in the convo

2017-07-18 23:27:50 UTC  

Can you obtain commodities without vouchers?

2017-07-18 23:28:00 UTC  

if you find them or don't steal them

2017-07-18 23:28:10 UTC  

Who would throw away a voucher?

2017-07-18 23:28:13 UTC  

@Horse Shmeat Wait, so anything that is used to make money is private property if not owned by the state or it's equivalent?

2017-07-18 23:28:18 UTC  

And that didn't answer my question

2017-07-18 23:28:21 UTC  

If a man is starving

2017-07-18 23:28:32 UTC  

Can he walk into a store room without a voucher and receive aid?

2017-07-18 23:28:39 UTC  

Despite not working?

2017-07-18 23:28:52 UTC  

His needs would be met throught distribution

2017-07-18 23:29:00 UTC  

food is not a commoditie

2017-07-18 23:29:05 UTC  

you need it to survive

2017-07-18 23:29:12 UTC  

>you don't need food to survive

2017-07-18 23:29:24 UTC  

my sides

2017-07-18 23:29:30 UTC  

that was an error

2017-07-18 23:29:33 UTC  

let me edit it

2017-07-18 23:29:41 UTC  

I tried to say you need it to survive

2017-07-18 23:29:46 UTC  

it is not a commoditie