Message from @reedpopper

Discord ID: 374283480999395348


2017-10-29 19:46:06 UTC  

maybe we can tackle that more simply

2017-10-29 19:46:12 UTC  

General concepts

2017-10-29 19:46:22 UTC  

give an example of a general concept

2017-10-29 19:46:25 UTC  

could you be a bit more specific

2017-10-29 19:46:27 UTC  

The immaterial is conceptual

2017-10-29 19:46:34 UTC  

Words perhaps?

2017-10-29 19:46:40 UTC  

Any given thing we can think of

2017-10-29 19:46:50 UTC  

That is tied to the world yet is above it/out of it

2017-10-29 19:46:53 UTC  

"immaterial" is a meaningless symbol as it does not designate anything

2017-10-29 19:46:55 UTC  

"Materialism is a form of philosophical monism which holds that matter is the fundamental substance in nature, and that all things, including mental aspects and consciousness, are results of material interactions."

2017-10-29 19:46:59 UTC  

R E A D

2017-10-29 19:47:17 UTC  

@big fat memes But it is not *just* matter

2017-10-29 19:47:27 UTC  

what else is it then

2017-10-29 19:47:33 UTC  

"In contrast to materialism, idealism concedes the primary of consciousness, which means consciousness exists before material, consciousness creates and determines material, not vice versa. Idealism theories believe consciousness is the origin of the world and aim to explain the existing world by mental causes."

2017-10-29 19:47:40 UTC  

I contend that consciousness, or what can be reckoned by the conscious, is not material

2017-10-29 19:47:51 UTC  

>muh idealism

2017-10-29 19:47:53 UTC  

Wrong argument

2017-10-29 19:48:01 UTC  

what is consciousness

2017-10-29 19:48:19 UTC  

What doth life?

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/374283329387888640/1504925005231.png

2017-10-29 19:48:28 UTC  

then what are you, a pluralist, a dualist, an idealist or a materialist because these are the only options?

2017-10-29 19:48:55 UTC  

if you do not have clearly defined terms for debating then don't bother making any claims at all since you don't actually believe anything

2017-10-29 19:49:08 UTC  

I am none of those

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/374283533973323779/Zeno.jpg

2017-10-29 19:49:12 UTC  

anything that can be said can be said clearly

2017-10-29 19:49:20 UTC  

Then what are you?

2017-10-29 19:49:34 UTC  

@reedpopper That is such a stubborn way to think

2017-10-29 19:49:40 UTC  

Super gay

2017-10-29 19:49:46 UTC  

Jesus christ this is like one of these videos where a fucking idiot gets basic maths explained to them

2017-10-29 19:49:51 UTC  

my sides

2017-10-29 19:49:57 UTC  

@big fat memes Wrong argument

2017-10-29 19:50:31 UTC  

How the fuck did you manage to go through life being this much of a fucking brainlet?

2017-10-29 19:50:42 UTC  

Tell us what you are then

2017-10-29 19:50:48 UTC  

If you're not a materialist or an idealist

2017-10-29 19:50:57 UTC  

I have gotten through life because my brain is huge

2017-10-29 19:51:04 UTC  

soyboys go through life with daddy's money and mommy's tendies, as usual

2017-10-29 19:51:06 UTC  

I know Scots have small minds

2017-10-29 19:51:11 UTC  

But this is ridiculous

2017-10-29 19:51:20 UTC  

do you have friends

2017-10-29 19:51:22 UTC  

@reedpopper You calling me a soyboy?

2017-10-29 19:51:28 UTC  

can you answer the question you debate dodging retard

2017-10-29 19:51:39 UTC  

if you're not a materialist or an idealist then what are you?

2017-10-29 19:51:42 UTC  

where did you find this guy