Message from @Kek

Discord ID: 399789483303632906


2018-01-08 02:45:46 UTC  

There is a lot of confusion, unknowing, and lies around it.

2018-01-08 02:47:07 UTC  

My view on it, is that it started as a crop famine, and due to stalin being stalin, he made the situation 10X worse than actually fixxing it, plus he had a disliking for the ukranian anarchists.

2018-01-08 02:48:32 UTC  

@Deleted User So why do you think Communism is worse that Natsoc if the Holodmor wasn't deliberate?

2018-01-08 02:49:39 UTC  

Does a crop famine and an internment camp determine every part of two beliefs?

2018-01-08 02:52:04 UTC  

@Deleted User You claimed a big problem with Communism is that it leads to many people dying ,and as far as I know you that is all you have said is wrong with Communism.

2018-01-08 02:52:46 UTC  

@Donitz Did I associatr every death for communism with the crop famine?

2018-01-08 02:53:36 UTC  

@Deleted User Did you?

2018-01-08 02:54:29 UTC  

Oh my fucking god.......
No, obviously not.

2018-01-08 02:55:58 UTC  

@Deleted User Where in the Communist manifesto does it advocate for violence ?

2018-01-08 03:45:04 UTC  

>Trumps been president for almost a year
>still don’t have a job

Explain yourselves, shitlords

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/399770458213318656/omj80kacgway.jpg

2018-01-08 03:47:08 UTC  

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/308950154222895104/399770978126659585/20621842_1426142737435440_4779596497230808506_n.png

2018-01-08 04:00:30 UTC  

@esgee Source?

2018-01-08 04:07:30 UTC  

ikr

2018-01-08 04:07:59 UTC  

_young, right-wing, authoritarian_

2018-01-08 04:08:07 UTC  

one of these things is not like the other lol

2018-01-08 04:08:43 UTC  

@Comrade Skeltal >Young >Authoritarian Yeah no

2018-01-08 04:46:37 UTC  

Man this other discord linked from leftypol is shit

2018-01-08 04:47:00 UTC  

It just groups all ‘radical’ ideologies together including fascists

2018-01-08 04:58:11 UTC  

Fascism is for actual brainlets

2018-01-08 04:59:23 UTC  

The State is never the highest good. Power comes from the people. The State is simply a tool for the advancement of the interests of its people.

2018-01-08 05:00:40 UTC  

That’s why the Roman Empire fell; the citizens had no incentive to hold allegiance to a government that didn’t care for *their* interests and wasn’t accountable to *them*

2018-01-08 05:03:12 UTC  

Why do you think Nazi Germany was so much more stable and powerful than Fascist Italy? The Nazis held their people (the “Völk”) in a higher regard than the state itself, so the Germans actually had a reason to support the regime. Italians were simply bullied into supporting Mussolini, so of course they turned on him at first chance.

2018-01-08 05:04:15 UTC  

Please note I’m not in any way endorsing Nazism, it’s just the closest comparison to Fascism that highlights the latter’s pitfalls

2018-01-08 05:06:04 UTC  

The pre-Stalinist USSR had public support because it was a people’s movement. The USSR lost its favor with the citizenry when Stalin turned it into an oppressive state that ignored the interests of the proletariat.

2018-01-08 05:06:22 UTC  

Is that pasta

2018-01-08 05:06:29 UTC  

No

2018-01-08 05:07:38 UTC  

The state evolved with increasing social complexity, centralization occurs when populations become too large and complex to manage

2018-01-08 05:08:40 UTC  

The aim of the state is to resolve contradictions and conflicts in mass society

2018-01-08 05:09:06 UTC  

You can’t have a stateless society without reverting to a prior social form

2018-01-08 05:09:18 UTC  

Centralization isn’t necessarily a problem, the problem comes when the state forgets who it is accountable to.

2018-01-08 05:10:14 UTC  

The state isn’t an organism that remembers or forgets things, that kind of organic conception of the state is actually fascist and derived from Spengler etc. it’s a bureaucracy, and that’s ok.

2018-01-08 05:10:35 UTC  

I’m a managerialist, new world order now

2018-01-08 05:11:16 UTC  

Actually communism, fascism and liberal democracy are all forms of managerial govt

2018-01-08 05:11:27 UTC  

Only one survived

2018-01-08 05:13:00 UTC  

If you actually compare the ideologies from as unbiased a standpoint as possible, Stalinism much more closely resembles Strasserism than it does Communism. I’d go as far as to say that real Communism as an ideology died when Leon Trotsky was assassinated by one of Stalin’s thugs.

2018-01-08 05:14:46 UTC  

It’s easy to say that when we don’t know what Trotsky would have done if actually in power...the failure of international revolution made it somewhat inevitable that the USSR would have been an authoritarian nationalist state...would Trotsky have made a difference? I’m not convinced

2018-01-08 05:17:47 UTC  

International revolution could have happened at least within the confines of an expanding, imperialist USSR if it had taken the effort to replace Russian nationalism with global Proletarian identity. Convincing workers of other countries that they shared the interests of the USSR could have led to more successful revolutions and eventual assimilation into the Union.

2018-01-08 05:17:51 UTC  

I identify with Mournier’s personalist manifesto but idk how that would look like in practice...ideology is mostly LARPing for intellectuals

2018-01-08 05:19:36 UTC  

Hard to convince them that they shared the interests of the USSR when the USSR was busy being imperialist and stoking nationalist fears in other countries

2018-01-08 05:20:47 UTC  

But relitigating history isn’t very enlightening, things happened the way they did and moving forward without falling into purity spirals is the best praxis

2018-01-08 10:04:52 UTC  

@Deleted User ur shit makes no sense