Idk. I dont think i will

Please don't lol

Pretty sure i promised id try not to

Lol

Soo... either the phrase "the people" means one thing in the entire Bill of Rights or it doesn't. I am asking you both which of do you think is accurate.

Does the phrase mean the same thing in the first 10 Amendments or different things. We can focus specifically on the 1st, 2nd and 4th... for simplicity sake... if you wish... but its entirely up to you.

Depends on the IQ temperature in the room tho

@JD~Jordan it depends on what "is" is

youre seriously just getting into pedantic games

"the people" is too granular and depends on the sentence its used in quite obviously

I mean it's different (holy deja vu there for a moment) based on if the bill of rights is saying something is an individual right, limiting federal rights, or delegating rights to the state (e.g: the people)

There are positive and negative rights.

Go read the fucking Amendments... 1st, 2nd and 4th.... each contain the phrase "the people" do you think it means the same thing in all of them or not...

Its not a fucking trick question.... Its not a gotcha. I am trying to understand your positions.

Ive answered all of your questions... I ask you guys 1 and your run like my 8th graders that forgot we were having a test

Whats the question here, yall? ...i know everything so i could prolly just answer it for u guys

(Jk lol)

@Joe Snow hes trying to say the 2nd amendment doesnt count

I absolutely see what you mean by that... so let's narrow it down. The 1st, 2nd and 4th... does the phrase "the people" mean the same thing?

Or make it easy... are they all taking about "the SAME people" (obviously this has nothing to do with slaves or not citizens - its not a trick question)

When the 1st Amendment says "the people" is it talking about the same people that the 2nd Amendment is talking about when it says "the people" and same with the 4th Amendment?

I honestly don't know why you ask that question. Is "the people" equal to "the people"? seems like a pretty "HMMMM." question.

Like: "Why would you ask me this?"

Wow. Ok.

Who are "the people" that is referred to in the 1st Amendment?

Citizens.

Ok thanks. I agree

Citizens.

And who are "the people" in the 2nd?

Already answered.

I assume you knew what I was typing

Ok... and the same for the 4th, right?

Citizens.

cool

So here is my honest question... knowing that how do you say that we can prohibit felons from owning weapons... but the first and 4th Amendments protect them the exact same way

lol good call ImNotGas.

see?

i knew where he was going

I'm actually not against felons owning firearms.

1st Amendment doesn't care if you are a felon... neither does the 4th.... so why does the 2nd?

What is the LEGAL argument?

felons can get a restitution of rights

Actually they do. They lose a ton of rights.

Not just the second.

LOL... ok fair enough. But the Supreme Court says the 2nd Amendment only applies to "law abiding, responsible" citizens....

So what is the legal argument?

Im also a rare breed of conservative who isnt against felons possessing firearms